Do you have to feed all the Black Candies to one pet or can it be multiple because the one I fed the first one to never gets hungry but all my other pets do...

As far as I know, it has to be the same pet.

Actually, it doesn't matter which pet you're feeding them to. You can feed them to 25 different pets and it will still count. :)

Oh. Well. DON'T LISTEN TO ME THEN, I WAS WRONG LOL. knows all.

Actually, it can be any pet or combo of pets! OH I LEAVE PAGES OPEN AND REPLY LATER WHOOPS.

lolol @ this board :P