SPOILER (click to toggle)
I think the minion just needs to be on by the 10th loss, not necessarily the whole time. I know we track the loss number and if the minion is there, but not them together the whole time? That might be way some of you are seeing the challenger unlock after just a few losses (and switch the minion).
I'm pleased how long it took you guys, though. TIME TO TOP IT NEXT MONTH.
Do you have any more hints about what exactly the minion has to be? Because I'm pretty sure I had over 10 losses with the first minion I tried, but it didn't work until I switched it. Even though the first minion was similar to the minion that worked.
SPOILER (click to toggle)
It's like a small pool of items with a theme of like dead/graveyard/bones/zombie? I tried to pull from Graveyard Quests and restockables so that it was just one item everyone was going for! There's no general answer like anything with 'bone' in the name or anything though, sorry!
SPOILER (click to toggle)
Alright thanks. I was just wondering because wasn't working even though did, which seemed odd, but if it's only a few items I guess it makes sense.
SPOILER (click to toggle)
That item didn't pop up when I was searching for things because I was specifically looking for items with the type of 'minion'. :x
Makes sense. At least we know a couple that are pretty common and cheap, so it shouldn't really be an issue for people.
Yeah, I tried to make sure to grab cheap things or like ... still obtainable things to use! Kind of like with the challenger last month, we had a pool of different black cats that would work so it wasn't everyone scrambling for one.
Oh, really? I thought it was just the that worked for last month's, but there are other ones?
I guess once people realized that one worked, everyone used it. I don't remember seeing any others being mentioned, so IDK if anyone noticed that others would work.
You Won! You have defeated Prodigy 5 times! You won a(n) Impossible token to use in the battle shop! Prodigy drops: Prodigys Eyeball The Void Scroll Tome of Water Quark Tome of Light Tome of Darkness You earned 32805 sP for beating Prodigy! Cynde earned 4724 EXP Points!
Yaaaaaay!
you are on the roll today! :) gj
art by amazing
Thank you kindly. ^_^
Also I really like the art in your post~
You've found a Hidden Opponent! Mathis challenges you to a fight in the Battle Coliseum!
[Spoiler] Used my pet Calibrate. Made him my active pet, and gave him a Zombie Kitten minion. Then just went and battled Prodigy a bunch until I got the notification. It took 8 battles for me. [/Spoiler]
Thank you for all of the help here!
Okay, I give up. I have done all of the above and I can't get the challenger. What gives?
Am up to 20 losses and have switched my minion multiple times. I effing give up.
You've found a Hidden Opponent!
Mathis challenges you to a fight in the Battle Coliseum!
I wish I could go back in time..
- SPOILER (click to toggle)
I think try not switching your minion and maybe just use the Zombie Kitten to be sure. Amber said she thinks it needs to be equipped for the 10th loss?
2 Oracle quests today (I swear I haven't had 1 in a year).
time.
You Won! You have defeated Unstable Snow Fairy Kuuipo earned 3500 EXP Points!
12 out of 31.

Mathis challenges you to a fight in the Battle Coliseum!
Finally...Haneul wants his normal minion back
You've found a Hidden Opponent! Mathis challenges you to a fight in the Battle Coliseum!
Tarrant has no normal minion so I let him play with a zombie kitten for a while; 8 losses for me
You Won!
You have defeated Mathis 5 times!
Weapons and stuff, for anyone wanting
[spoiler=enabled and disabled]Freezing, Blessings, Curses, Healing, and Stealing are all enabled
He doesn't seem to freeze or have curses, and blasting seems pretty consistent
weapons
Hammer and Chisel (at least 3)
18-20:dmg:physical: 6-7:dmg🔥 6-7:dmg:dark:
7:block:physical:
Iron Anvil (at least 2) 25-28:dmg:physical: 7-12:dmg:magma: 4:block:physical: 4:block🔥 4:block:dark: 4:block:magma:
Red Hot Tongs (at least 2) 14-16:dmg🔥 8:dmg:light: 16-19:dmg:magma:
Full Slack Tub (at least 2)
4-6:dmg🔥 4-6:dmg🧊 15-18:dmg:water:
12:block🔥
175:heal:
loot
Random Stuff
Win 5 [/spoiler]
You've found a Hidden Opponent! Mathis challenges you to a fight in the Battle Coliseum!
i dont know what triggered it to be honest i was just happy that all of a sudden the you found a hidden opponent showed up :):)
almost got a pet from the pound because i tought all my pets where to strong .lucky for me that was not needed....boekenworm was the one i was fighting with when it all of the sudden popped up