Haha, I think we're all too opinionated about food for this game... I'm not big on many fruity desserts, so honestly, both of those sound fairly terrible, but I'd pick the strawberry thing over lime. Lime is the worst. Lime is only good fresh in Mexican food, or occasionally in key lime pie things. But only because key limes are somehow gentler than real limes...

Cotton candy or candy apples?

Candy Apples!!! Yuuuum! Ugh, I've actually been craving them since Halloween.

Tacos or Burritos?

Oh... That's really hard... I guess... maybe burritos? By a tiny margin. But basically all mexican food is amazing. It's a real bummer here. We went to a "mexican" restaurant, and basically anything you ordered had the same ingredients. The only difference between the "burrito" and the "fajita" was that one you had to put together yourself. And none of them were really burritos, and they didn't serve rice or beans as a side with the main dish. Just a salad. -_-

Let's see... Sponge candy or licorice?

licorice

This is a virtual game, so part of the entertainment IMO is the answer any user chooses to give. In RL I would eat one or the other or sometimes both of the foods offered without complaint or any indication that it was vomitrocious, because y'know polite. Here, I will be silly.

Peanut Brittle or Rock Candy (oh, say coconut flavor)?

Peanut Brittle.

Monster M&M Cookies or Sea Salt Chocolate Chip Cookies?

The M&M ones

Sausage or bacon?

Hmmm... If the sausage is summer sausage, or a cheese-filled Johnsonville Bratwurst, I would definitely pick that. If we're talking breakfast sausage or bacon, I would normally choose bacon, but I haven't had proper breakfast sausage in forever, so....

Sausage?

Totally agree. There is nothing that has been mentioned in this forum that I WOULDN'T eat if it was served. But I love to hear what people would pick and WHY they would pick it. The why is often the most interesting part!

Let's see... macarons or macaroons?

Macaroon

Divinity or Lemon Bars?

Lemon Bars.

Chili Cheese Dog or Frito Pie?

I guess the chili cheese dog, because Fritos always made me feel a bit queasy. I don't like how they smell. Weird, I suppose...

Hmm... Reese's Puffs of Cocoa Puffs (cereals)?

Cocoa puffs! I love the chocolate milk they leave behind.

Pop-tarts or toaster strudels?

Haha, yes, the milk is lovely...

Hmm... I guess the idea of toaster strudels sounds really good, so I would like to try those. Non-toaster strudels are usually pretty good. I've only ever actually had poptarts, though. So I can't say 100% for sure.

Let's see.

Brussel sprouts or spinach? :O

That's so tough! I love them both! Spinach is more versatile, so let's go with that, I guess.

Ham or Spam?

Ham.

Crab Cake or Potato Latkes?

Potato latkes, with sour cream. I loooove them!

Swedish meatballs, or sweet-and-sour meatballs?

Sweetish meetballs, since ive never had sweet and sour meatballs!

pulled pork or cheeseburgers??

Oh, pulled pork, definitely! But maybe that's because cheeseburgers are everywhere in the world, and super easy to make, but pulled pork is harder to make (it takes so much time to slow cook), and European restaurants are entirely unaware that it exists, so I have that much more rarely...

peanut brittle or chocolate covered pretzels? (I'm already starting to think about what treats I want to make for the holidays this year!)

Chocolate covered pretzels!

Divinity or marzipan?

Oh, divinity. Marzipan is a dime a dozen around here, all year round. But divinity you can't find. I know how to make it, but I also know despite the fact people in my family are excellent cooks, and very good with candy, divinity has murdered more than one mixer. The sugar syrup can cool too much as you mix it in, harden to fast, and grind the gears of your mixer!

So, I'm afraid to make it myself, so I always buy it at Catholic church bazaars and bake sales. :O

Banana bread or zucchini bread?

Banana Bread.

Cherry Cheesecake or Blond Brownies?