do you have Lizard Minion Trap in your inventory?

also, all my pets except for my battle one has 0 health, maybe it can help

-rubs back of neck-

I give up... I'm having no luck with any of this and I'm getting sad. -punches Gunter in his face- Nah nothing.

check my post above you, maybe it's this.

Maybe have a pet or many pets with 0 health or have the lizard trap in your inventory (froggy had this item too)

I have the trap. I'm gonna get all my pets' health down stares at the massive amount of them

If that doesn't work then idk at this point. I can't spend hours and hours trying to figure out something that seems to have no shared answer.

It's like dealing with the Troll....ridiculous and unfun.

Only one of my pets is in the Inn and nearly all of them are either hungry/unhappy or both. I do have the trap in my inventory.

I went in with my battle pet at 0 hp, and I have the trap in my inventory, that didn't seem to work. I didn't try it with all my pets though. Edit: You've found a Hidden Opponent!

Gunter challenges you to a fight in the Battle Coliseum!

Taking all my pets to 0 hp did it.

You've found a Hidden Opponent!

Gunter challenges you to a fight in the Battle Coliseum!

stupid

I'm trying to get all mine down to 0 health now, I'll let you know.

got all my pets to 0 health, not working... also not all my pets with 0/10 hunger (I had them hungry before, then I put them in the lodge dor no reason, apparently...)

[edit]

Yeah I'm sick of trying.... :( I just got a pet that doesn't even battle... be put into a battle just to be beaten... and still wasn't good enough. I don't see why you'd have to have all your pets dead and unhappy... that's overkill in my books just for a challenger who really is gonna be fighting YOUR pet anyway... lol. Gunter you... need to lay off the booze you jerk.

Hmmm I waited. I'll keep trying with a few other pets. I even made one pet active in case that had anything to do with it. Might have to wait for my pets to be absolutely miserable and with no HP.

Yep - done that. I'm up to 16/27 and still nothing.

o.O; I am completely at a loss then maybe it's something else. I only sent 11 of them to slaughter

I did not abuse Pylot! :D

And I bet he loves you for it~

I've got 2 pets with 0/10 health and several hungry but happy... and several hungry/unhappy. I've gone to the link and he still won't fight me. Hmmmmm.

It ate my reply I guess o_O It was redirecting me to the old brewery link, which was the issue.

I go to that link but it keeps changing the moment the page loads.... it won't load the page the link is supposed to go to.

Now I am not entirely certain if the 0 health thing is right, although Sov unlocked him with 0 health. Are their multiple ways of getting your pet to 0 health?