Um. Why does the Mallarchy look like that STILL? Why can't it be like all the other GYs? Why does the Mallarchy have to look like food? :C
OH HAY GUYS, KEEP THE NAME CALLIN' TO A MIN, YES? -hypocrite-
And if 'you' people haven't read the previous comments on revamps before, get it through your thick skull. Being blunt is one thing, being an arrogant, whiny, and stuck up brat is another. If you're going to show your displeasure about something, do it in a civilized way, without harshly insulting the art, idea, personality, whatever the hell else there is to criticize about it.
Btw, this isn't real life 'kay. We can interpret roast ducks however we want to, and keep in mind that not everybody around here pays attention to the tiny details such as the utter sliminess and whatnot. Most of us prefer not to go that far actually. =|
As for my opinion on the revamps, I can't say I'm fond of them either. The art is beautiful as always, but I have to agree the Clawsion seems to have lost a bit of its wicked attitude. Could be the way the old one had more sunken eyes and generally had a much more darker look. And the Mallarchy isn't bad at all, but it's reminding me a bit too much of the cutesy Donald Duck. I however do like the scars on the Clawsion and the overall detail done in the Mallarchy's skin. Well what can I say; I never wanted either of them, since neither species really appeals to me, but the humor's still there. Keep up the nice artwork~
/END WALL OF TEXT
They both look better..i want the Clawsion! ^^
Ovation and veganphenoix must be bffs. I have never heard the term 'carnist' before and when I google it, little to nothing comes up (other than a single article that doesn't load and an uninformative youtube video... and some people with the last name 'Carnist.') Obviously it's not something that is used widely and I doubt it will ever become as commonly used as 'racism' or 'misogyny.' Do everyone a favour and get over the fact that people eat meat. Seriously.
Wow... I don't know how the "and don't feel so" fits into my first sentence... I was probably going to write something else but decided not to.
Hurrah bad grammar?
I like the new Clawsion and don't feel so and don't have any feelings that oppose the change. But that might be just because I've never owed/wanted/cared about the GY Clawsion or Clawsions in general.
While the new Clawsion is much more impressive art wise as well as looks more like its actual species than the old one I still can see why people don't like it. The new one has this proud look and is kind of cute too, where as the old one looks more... well... dead, which is kind of the point of GY pets.
The clawsion reminds me of Binky Barnes from Arthur. xD
Hey, cool. Ovation blocked me for calling him/her/it an idiot. It's almost as if they don't understand what they did wrong!
I was going to get a graveyard clawsion....
Now that idea is trashed. 
I love the way the old one looked better
Gahhhrgh Ive always loathed the graveyard mallarchy =[ Its a funny original idea but just.. Id seriously never get one its hideous to me- that is functionality wise, not aesthetics.
Mallarchy looks more edible. XD
Love the Clawsion. 
Definitely needed the revamp.
I like the new art; Beautifully soft colors and lineart. But-- the Clawsion revamp just completely lost it's style. To me, it looks like another cuddly disney-style lion. I also would like to have seen the yellow teeth and claws. The stitches and scars are a nice touch, but the expression just lacks what the old one was. The eyes look absolutely alive. To me, it doesn't look so much dead, as it looks more like a ratty stuffed animal. -- My opinions.
The clawsion looks like a bull dog.
I love these revamps (though I miss the skull on the old Mallarchies forehead, but I am far from disappointing). Great job to the artist(s) !
And to Veganpheniox, shut the Hell up you pretentious ass.
I need to get a Mallarchy. Thanks artists!
I concur, Bastit.
that mallarchie is sorta creepy xD
wow amazing! cant wait to see all the other revamps now!
<label id="item_An_Idiots_Guide_to_Constructive_Criticism_1" onMouseOver='showPlus("135138")'>
<a name="item_An_Idiots_Guide_to_Constructive_Criticism_1" href="" id="wishlistadd_135138" onClick='addWishList("An+Idiots+Guide+to+Constructive+Criticism",135138,"item_An_Idiots_Guide_to_Constructive_Criticism_1")'>
A lot of people here needs a copy of this. 
Lol! Well now im hungry.
I love the revamped Clawson, especially all the little details it has that make it love fucking squee worthy. However the Mallarchy is sorta stupid, it's supposed to be a dead bird, not some idiots dinner. The humor that bred it is...lackluster and unimaginative at best, malicious and conceited at worst.
You fit your name. Carnist is an actual word that was coined in an academic work just like misogyny or racism were. Don't like it? Well isn't that too bad for you. Go watch your rape porn and cry about it.
As someone who worked under a veterinarian and with birds, I know what a dead bird looks like, the Mallarchy looks nothing like it. You can't even claim that a roast bird looks like that, since real roast birds look much more disgusting and slimy. An actual dead bird has all it's feathers, it's wings and tail don't look like stubs and the the body doesn't look so smooth. For someone who claims their roast bird taught them avian anatomy, you sure don't know that much
(please don't mind my double-posting! I forgot to add this)
But I've gotta say, applause for the mallarchie revamp. It's very funny. And the texture work is nice, got some awesome color-blends going on.
Mmm ... not a fan of the new clawsion. Oh the drawing is good, but the overall look is ... flat. The wings don't pop like the dark gray ones did. It's missing strong lines or dark shadows. And it lacks character. The old one was cute. This is one ... smug. Kinda looks like a jerk, if I were to give it a personality. Not true to the spirit of the old design.
One by one each of the graveyard pets that I liked have been changed. It's dropped to my least favorite color now.
If anyone's interested, here's the some comparisons against the old and new mallarchy.
I LIKE THEM BOTH AND THINK THEY ARE BOTH FABULOUS. ROASTED DUCK FTW. IMAGINATION. IT'S A GOOD THING.
ahem I do like the Clawison and his epic hero stance. It's cute, with a side of dangerous and an extra helping of crazy animal. <3 Nice job on both to the artist.
awww the clawsion looks cute ;P
Heh, I have to admit I lol-ed at the roasted chikin. CHKN!
I love the Mallarchy's roasted body, it makes it unique and stand out. These pets are dead, and dead duck-like birds tend to be roasted up for dinner XD
I like the revamped clawsion more though, something about its stance I think. It just looks tougher and more in-your-face than the older version, which never really held my interest.
Oh, I forgot to add this. Great detail in the art. Maybe the Mallarchy could have like a body, not a roasted body, though.
I love the new clawsion, great art!
Oh, and maybe it should be a little hunched or something. It looks a little valiant with the chest out :/
The Clawson is missing something...
At least one dead eye would be perfect to me
Love the new clawsion, it's a adorable, which you don't usually get from a GY pet d:
So, I do like both of them - but I feel as though the Clawsion has lost something. It doesn't look GY. Well, it LOOKS it, but it doesn't... feel it, y'know? It's just missing something. GREAT art, grand work on the artist's part, but.. it's missing something.
The mallarchy... well. xD I still dig the chicken joke, but I feel as though its no longer as funny. It's lost a little something, too, in transition. Something that made it... well, awesome. It's okay, great art as always, but... well, yes. Several recent revamps have, and other revamps have been AMAZING. I guess that's just how the ball rolls.
LOOOOVE both of these ♥ that clawsion especially omg ;___;
lol @ anyone offended by the mallarchy. are you kidding? it's more or less a roasted chicken. a pixel image of a roasted chicken. if you are offended by roasted chickens then i really think you need to develop a thicker skin /: seriously.
karateetee, please don't start drama. :| I love both of these revamps. Now the Clawsions are up-to-date and ready to eat your face! :B The Mallarchy art is great, but it's.. cuter. Which doesn't fit the color, but I love it. xD
I find the Mallarchy really offensive. I don't like the sight of ducks or any animal like that. I personally love ducks a lot, and have been around them for a long time, and it hurts me to see them that way.
But the other one, looks cool.
Hmm. To be honest, I liked the old Clawsion.
Honestly, I prefer the old clawison. The art is definitely an improvement, though.
Quote By NoirRaven:
; border: 1px solid ; font-family: georgia; font-size: 10;">Both have lost a lot of edge with their revamps. The Mallarchy is more cute than dead and the notion seems way less funny now. :/ I blame those cute, shiny eyes.
You have the world's stupidest opinions, did you know?
I love the clawsion! But I kind of want to eat the mallarchy...
Quote By noirraven:
; border: 1px solid ; font-family: georgia; font-size: 10;">The Clawsion... Let's face it, It always looked bitchin' with collars and it still does. I can't say the same for the revamp. Definitely should've kept the black on the wings/paws and the dark circles around the eyes. He is DEAD after all. Make him look it!It's dead, not an emo-tranny!
I will admit I love the Mallarchy, actually I like it a lot. O.o; The clawsion isn't bad looking either, but it just looks less cute I guess you could say? Either which way, bravo to the artists.
Oooooh I love the new clawison It's like a puppy with such a 'i'm tough, don't mess with me' look now. Attitude ftw!
WELL as someone who has a GY Clawsion (even though I have a redraw overlay) I want to express my love for the new Clawsion and gratitude to the artist. ;;
Poultry. Yum. :0
Not liking the mallarchy at all, I just used a GY potion on mine a few weeks ago. 
Its nice art but not my cup of tea and I'm sad about it.
I think the revamps look WAAAYYY better!!
The graveyard clawsion looks huggable now. Cute but not so, dark, evil, and graveyard like....?
The Clawison is absolutely adorable. I can't wait to get my loyalty box so I can get one.
Both of these revamps are amazing and most definitely a step up from what they were. 
.
Thank you so much to the artists. 