[item2=Tainted Keeper Skull Staff] [item2=Temple Guardians Axe Head] [item2=Cracked Satyr Blade Tip]

The smoked herb and smudge stick items are still in the Cash Shop under the Clothing tab. I would guess they'll probably stick around through the sale at least, since they haven't announced any more upcoming retirements yet.

Though it's possible they might be retired after the sale is over, since they were released during the Black Friday sale last year.

OH i didn't even see them asdfghjkl thanks for telling me! o:

and all the other Bobbleheads and all the other Emo Bubbles And all the other Chibi Plushies and all the other Chilly Teddy Plushies

This transformable minion never came back during the BF sale, or ever and it's transforming into collections items, minions and wears + the items that it's transforming into having the rarity wrong, they are not collection items because they were never part of a collection + it's not in the Theme Chance Machine along with the other transformable minions.

Seriously though, I'd like to see the following items back, even if not discounted:

Maybe these? They were last in the shop a few years back for BF (I think?). The collection they're part of doesn't ever go on sale since it was from that weird time before monthly donation presents. I think this is the base version that was sold in the shop. Unless I’m missing it, it’s not in the themed item chance. Plus I’d rather not have to gamble for unwanted garbage to get a gold turle:

+ other colors (maybe even the entire set tbh) -- can this become a regular trunk where you can buy whatever bit you want by itself? /

It's an edible minion! Perfect for this months theme.

I always have a limit on how much I can spend during the BF sale and some of the retired items are only available during the sale which makes it all the more difficult to choose.

One of the things I love to see are books. There are always wearbles throughout the year but it makes me happy to see the retired books return because I can only afford a few each year and there are so many I want. The Encrusted series, the Dragon series, the flower fairy series and the series with different crafts come to mind but they are not the only ones I hope to see this year.

I also would LOVE to see the Chance machines discounted! I’ve been hoping for this for a few years now, maybe my wish will come true this year <3

Books Books Books!!

Plushies please ---

Chilly Teddy Collection

Chibi Collection

I think we'd all drop good money for those if you were a battler. Tbh