You Win:
Rean
If you had just gotten a little closer!
[Center]
[/center]
[item2=Fish Bones]
How did you manage to get that far away from the treasure?

[item2=Tadpole with Legs]
You were nowhere near it!

You Win:
Evish
You were nowhere near it!
[Center]
[/center]
You Win:
[item2=Fishy Fish]
You were so close!
[item2=Baby Creature]
How did you manage to get that far away from the treasure?

Baby Creature
You were nowhere near it!
[item2=Red Tackle Box]
You were nowhere near it!

You Win:
Mutated Fish
If you had just gotten a little closer!
[Center]
[/center]
[item2=Blue Bobber]
You were nowhere near it!

You Win:
[item2=Mutated Fish]
If you had just gotten a little closer!
You Win:
[item2=Kohaku Koi]
If you had just gotten a little closer!
Formerly known as its_just_me
(I started in March)
Wine is the answer
What was the question?
[item2=Whaddya Fish]
You were so close!

Cheap Fishing Pole
You were nowhere near it!