Tadpole
You were nowhere near it! :D :P
[item2=Shusui Koi]
How did you manage to get that far away from the treasure?

You Win:
Bagged Guppy
If you had just gotten a little closer!
[Center]
[/center]
[item2=Tadpole with Legs]
You were nowhere near it!

You Win: [item2=Book Worm] If you had just gotten a little closer!
[item2=Balloon Fish]
How did you manage to get that far away from the treasure?

You Win:
[item2=Tadpole]
You were nowhere near it!
Hi Utsuri Koi
If you had just gotten a little closer!
[item2=Regular Worm]
You were nowhere near it!

You Win:
[item2=Ribbit]
If you had just gotten a little closer!
Formerly known as its_just_me
(I started in March)
Wine is the answer
What was the question?
[item2=Baby Crocodile]
If you had just gotten a little closer!

You Win:
[item2=Small School of Neons]
You were so close!