oops. Sorry! I will get busy now!

No worries, it's all quite confusing to be honest D:

Can you add me to page 8 as well? Have all the items for it, now to battle!

Added you :) Added you and accepted your join request :) Please read the rules in the first post and check the group forums for important threads you have to post in! Added you to the list! Please join the ping group # trolling (remove the space) and Please read the rules in the first post and check the group forums for important threads you have to post in!

Still no joy with P.27 weapons. Am I supposed to test them again tomorrow??

We do like to test them periodically, so ideally yes. Definitely test them again if the troll is defeated and reset again.

Pages 3 and 25 tested as of now (other than the Chancellor's War Shield and Diamond Sceptre of the Terrier Queen), no luck.

had tested page 8, no results - if I didn't know how hard this one would be the longer I waited, I would totally have given up by now.

I found the current item and posted it in 'The Winning Item is....!' thread in the group.

Someone let me know once it's broken so I can finish :P

Hey guys, sorry I'm not a member of your group, but I won just a while back with a repeat of Goldbrand, so be sure to check weapons that have already been used for the win.

Is there still a list of weapons that have worked floating around? If someone already won with a repeat of one of those, then maybe it's a random one of a limited group of weapons or something.

Items that have worked thus far:

or - they were used at the same time for someone to win, but I'm inclined to believe it is the latter weapon.

It makes me more confident, because we've had a few repeats, that it is hopefully only a tier 1 / tier 2 weapon.

Me, too. I hope the item pool is smaller than we yet realize and that we can have a complete list of all possible weapons one day :)

Is the Goldbrand still active? I don't want to end my 5th battle if people are still fighting, but if someone already has their 5 I'd like to move on to some other testing.

It is no longer active :(

Thanks!

I tend to agree on the Icicle Knife since the battle star breaks. Have there been other breakable/one use items that won? That would considerably narrow your choices.

Yes, the Unadorned Silver Sword was used to win, it is breakable.