Black liquorice is probably a gift from the gods, oh man.

Sponge cake or pound cake?

Pound cake

Carrot cake or Red velvet cake?

Tough choices! Carrot.

Chocolate Pudding or Strawberry Jello?

Chocolate pudding if I am hungry but strawberry jello if I just want a snack.

Slushie or a Pop ice(those freezy flavored ices in the plastic tubes)?

Slushie, because there's insulation --===---

Ice Cream Bar or Ice Cream Sandwich?

Ice cream sandwich!!!

Blueberry muffin or cream cheese danish?

Cream cheese danish sounds tastier!

Mac and cheese or spaghetti?

Mac and cheese and pearl onions and chervil --====-----'''

Pizaa or meatloaf?

Pizza!

Pancakes or Waffles?

Pancakes, especially if they're my grandma's recipe (buttermilk and whipped egg whites make the fluffiest and loveliest ones)

blueberry syrup or maple syrup?

Maple Syrup, all the way! Candy Corn or Caramel Apples?

Candy corn. What a horrible thing to do to an apple. =====0000====

Popcorn Balls or Peanut Brittle?

Definitely peanut brittle.

Salmon or tuna?

Salmon, yum

Berries or Melons?

Did I pick either myself? Melons.

Citrus or Pomes?

Citrus.

Tator Tots or Chili Cheese Fries?

^ is that the opposite of "lime" color, as a Morostide disguise?

Tots. Chili is ok on french fries, but if there's cheese also, I'd rather have the real stuff: poutine. Which my browser thinks is a misspell.
-----0000----

Fish Sticks or Pigs in a Blanket?

Pigs in a Blanket.

Continue with appetizers:

Crab Cakes or Mushroom Vol-au-Vent?

Mushroom vol-au-vent!

nutella or peanut butter?

Nutella.

Peas or Carrots?