So this is what I've found:
Achievements that don't even exist on the new format: Split Personality: Mori
Achievements not marked as [RETIRED]: Trash collector Trivia Champion
Achievements I'm missing: Leviathan Harpooning - Level 6 ^ this actually had issues on the previous format. What I earned was 5/6, what was displayed in the past was 3/3 & 0/6, and what is now showing on the new format is 1/3 Extreme VIP ^ which everyone is missing it seems
Progress Lost: Sebastian Phoenix Visit -shows 0/500,000 instead of 157,758/500,000 Good Taxpayer -shows 0/5,000,000 instead of 709,193/5,000,000 Enraged and Erupting! -shows 0/70 instead of 57/70 Free all the Fairies! -shows 0/1,000 instead of 675/1,000 Rotten to the Manticore [RETIRED] -shows 0/5 instead of 2/5 Pylot Chaser [RETIRED] -shows 0/100 instead of 12/100
Oddly enough, number-wise, I have two more achievements than before. I'm assuming one is the Achievement Testing achievement but I don't know about the other one. I'm guessing it's a result of either the tier changes or that I earned something during this whole import thing and missed it.
Ok, now I have 913 achievements. So now I've lost 3. I'ts supposed to be 916 D:
These usually take a minute or two to start working, but I've been trying for a day and it just doesn't want to give me this achievement.

All my achievements seem to have loaded correctly, at least I haven't noticed any missing ones.
However, there seems to be something wrong with the progress tracking for games. I played a few games of Saheric Slide on 3x3 yesterday, and again today, but the Three-Ring Circus achievement shows no progress. The achievement for Divine Discs doesn't seem to be showing any progress either, when I just played a game. Quests seem to be tracking correctly.
Also, there seems to be something off with the search function. Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't. I think it just keeps searching when it doesn't find any matches? Does it search just the title, or does it also search through the summary? It would be awesome if it searched through the summary too, it would make it easier to find all the achievements relating, for example, to a specific game.
Like others have said, the progress on some of my achievements is off:
However for some achievements the progress is correct, e. g.
The list above is probably not complete. I haven't looked at all of the achievements. So there might be more where my progress is off.
I'm having a problem with quests updating. For example, I've been doing my quests, but for the past few days, Cinthia has been stuck at 972 out of 1000. I probably should have gotten the 1000 achievement by now.
Big Spender is not updating correctly
I did 6 Drunk Carl quests and then got the achievement for "help Carl with 1 quest"
[tot=shinteki]
Not because we should, because we could.
I'm still missing a couple of Achievements it seems, sadly I only know one for sure which is the VIP-Achievement from the Peekaboo Festival. :/
~ Did you go into the old wardrobe and the new wardrobe? I had to do that a couple of times, then back to the achievement page. It took, I don't remember exactly, but more than 5 minutes to finally show up for the one I completed yesterday.
So far, these are the problems with my achievements.
Progress Lost:
I'm also not seeing any progress on my achievements. I've played Caliph's Tomb over and over for the past few days, sending my scores and so on, and my progress count on Walk Like a Saheric is still stuck at 584/1000. The same is true of Numbah Cruncha for Subeku, my progress hasn't moved from 56/100.
I think a few tweaks would make the new achievement page even better:
I have all the lonely penguin plashes, but no achievement (and it doesn't show I have all of them.)
I'm still short more than 200 achievements. That's WAY more than Mori/Nori.
EDIT:
Now that I griped about it here, my missing achievements magically appeared. It was 845 before I posted and went to 1081 after I posted even though I didn't re-import the achievements. Is there some sort of time lag to the updated numbers actually showing after it's been reloaded?
just got the "Aw, Cheer Up!" achievement...well I thought I did. got the last penguin requred (the silver one) but the achievement didn't pop up for me nor is the achievement marked as "completed". basically I have all the items but I didn't get the achievement
Still missing extreme vip when I imported the other day my count was 1.129 now it is sitting at 1,126
Alright, I'm looking into all of the specific achievements! Thank you guys for finding those ones that don't want to import, I'm going to take a look and figure out why today :)
💖 ✨ 🤗
I missing at least 4 achievements ):
I'm still getting achievements that I already got before - just got the achievement for laying five flowers. The counts are also off for how many flowers I laid - it says 21, but I know I put more than that down.
Also, the vending machine maniac is at 776 (now, I am not sure if it keeps count of the number of different items, or just the total number of items - but I should be up to at least 1500 if it's just the number of times you've vended - I've done my 250 times a day every day since Sat for sure and I know that I vending some before Sat).
I've also lost three achievements since yesterday - was at 174, am at 171 today.
When I tried looking at my achievements, I also got this error: You have Warning: Invalid argument supplied for foreach() in /www/subeta.net/include/user.php on line 14 177 achievements!
Give me a flower! <3 | Trick or Treat | TPing | Egging
[center]