[Item=Cream-Choc Pudding Beanbag]

Plz it's the last beanbag I need!

This is more of a general comment, rather than specific items. I just think this is the most appropriate place to make a suggestion about returning old books. They are always in short supply and high demand. A user only has one avatar to clothe, one sticker/plushie/minion etc that they put in their collections, usually only one pet that they feed. Books are frequently read to multiple pets. Since we cannot keep a book and read it to all of our pets, we must buy numerous copies. Those of us who battle face a greater pressure to read to all of our pets since it directly affects their performance.

What I would really like to see is a way to opt for "BOOKS only" anytime you bring back old items. Instead of having Carl hand out old Keel Hauliday items, why not also have Library quests reward old Keel Hauliday books? The same at Morostide and other holidays when you bring back old items.

I know many people love getting these old gifts from Melody, but the only things of hers I want from years past are BOOKS. Obviously, this wonderful idea to return old favorites -- while no doubt delightful to many -- has been frustrating for me. I have all of her old books on my WL and need numerous copies of them. I have gotten a single copy of two books. I don't recall what else I have gotten because it all got tossed in my vault. I haven't even been successful in trading the older items I have for the books that I want this event.

I go through this every event. I know I am not alone, but I'm probably just the only one with a big enough mouth to speak up. I realize you have a great many people to try to please and that it is impossible to keep everyone happy all of the time. Just, please, going forward, keep the bibliophiles in mind.

I hope you have a joyous and healthy holiday season! May your life be as free from stress as possible...

What said is true for me too!! Books! BOOKS BOOKS and MORE BOOKS! :P (I read to all 21 of my pets - sometimes only 1 pet is able to be read to because the book is so rare!) :D Option to choose to get books only (like from Melody) or a quest (library is fine!) that gives old event books would be awesome!!

Item Name: Emperors Egg [item=Emperors Egg]

Item Original Location (It's okay if you don't know where this was released): It says Melody 2007 Calendar

PLEASE <3

It's one of only 3 more books I need. The other two are & - which would also be amazing to be able to acquire in other ways :')

2007 New Year Live Teddy Trivia prize

Only two in shops as of writing, at 35mil and 40mil. Would love to see a rerelease.

An updated list of plushies I would love to see come back:

Original Location: Trivia Priza

Original Location: Trivia Prize

Original Location: Trivia Prize

Original Location: Trivia Prize

Original Location: Morostide 2010: Holiday Shop item

Last Known Location: Crystal Shop

Last Known Location: Crystal Shop

Last Known Location: Councilors Cruise 2012

Last Known Location: Councilors Cruise 2012

Last Known Location: Councilors Cruise 2012

please :<

Not many left, and it's the time of year for it to turn up again 😭