Since the Malevolent Grimfruit is a minion, I'd like it if the Fake Malevolent Grimfruit was one as well, for consistency's sake.

I know "make this item a weapon" isn't part of this, but I don't know where else to put this. is for some reason not a weapon despite clearly being a knife.

Well, not necessarily every item that looks like a knife or something is a weapon, and I think staff probably want to try to cut down on the amount of weapons in the future because a lot of them never get used. But I can add it to the list and we'll see. :)

Hi, could I ask if someone has suggested this as book , please? Or is it for something else? (I am looking for books, because of the Achievement^^)

I can add those to the list, but it may fall under the same reasoning of not having regular scrolls be books (since they are used as battle items), and those scroll pieces are used in Genetech combos to make scrolls so they do have a purpose already.

Oh, that makes sense. Thank you for the fast helpful respose.^^

added to my WL just in case lol

could be edible. I'm sure there are weirder foods lol

I would like to suggest as a book since we have and other CDs as books.

I got the last week and went to put it in the Minion Zoo. Alas! It isn't a minion, but seems like it should be.

[Edit] Sorry, just realized wearables can't be minions. :(

Make these toys minions:

Angriest Paper Jack-o-Lantern Catfish Paper Jack-o-Lantern Happy Paper Jack-o-Lantern Kitty Face Paper Jack-o-Lantern Mustache Paper Jack-o-Lantern Omg No Paper Jack-o-Lantern Smug Paper Jack-o-Lantern Triumphant Evil Paper Jack-o-Lantern Winky Fishlips Paper Jack-o-Lantern

Why not make the trading cards readable?

Added the paper jack-o-lanterns to the first post.

The trading cards are on the rejected list because staff have said no to the idea when it's been brought up in the past. I'm not a staff member so I couldn't tell you exactly the reason why since I can't find any of those old posts from prior rejection. However, if I had to guess I would say it's because the trading cards are already their own collection and many of them are expensive enough as it is (like several million sP for one card), and books also have a tendency to be highly desired and expensive. So having them be both things would only make that worse.

Thank you for breaking my heart!

I'd like to suggest a few Delish items that could also be foods. My wallet thinks it's a terrible idea, but my pet thinks it's amazing.

Herbal Medicinal Wood should be edible?

Could be made edible?

Hi I dont know if this item has been mention. But I think the should be readable for pets.

Ah, I think it may have been mentioned before, but that one won't be turned into a book because it's already a wearable item.

Also just a note that the first post should be updated through this point.

Oh poo I was hoping, thanks for letting me know.