Maybe we're just not that bright... ;)

I have faith in you guys! Just keep visiting grumpy gus of a potion maker the next few days and trying different things :)

I'm very sad that we didn't think to do 's idea.

this would've been hilarious

I'm very excited to hear that the unlock has something to do with his character. I really was getting the feeling (completely my own) that y'all were trying to mock us!

I bummed myself out after reviewing the last few solutions and getting the same vibe that we didn't actually know WHY we angered them until the CS challenger appeared. It's more rewarding to not pay attention to the unlock and just enjoy the new challengers and lore so I think I'll go back to waiting for someone else to stumble upon the solution!

My headcanon was that he sings Tommy in the shower.

I'm thinking we need to bring him something, do something in his shop, or do something to our account since we have to go visit him to unlock him. If we just needed to do something elsewhere on the site then he would be unlocked on a different page...

/overanalyzes Amber's posts If he's grumpy and it takes time, I wonder if we have to wait until a certain day of the week (Monday) or until it's raining in Darkside?

I threw a seed into the gardens and promptly watered it oops, because maybe as a potions maker he gets really pissed when precious herbs/ingredients/plant life in general gets killed. And it takes time for them to die. I am probably so far from the answer but I try.

I'm not sure I have any ideas left in me 😂 I've tried all I can think of...

I have faith in you guys! Just keep visiting grumpy gus of a potion maker the next few days and trying different things

Grumpy Gus????

yo idk if anyone is interested but I'm pounding a couple pets that are t3 and t4

id rather them go to people that will maybe battle or train them and preferably not huge battle pet hoards. if anyone is starting out or doesn't have any massive pet yet, let me know

[pet not found] - tier 3 [pet not found] - tier 4

Oh hi everyone!

I'm just trying to see what sort of things are actual phobias, given that the cash shop challenger that accompanies the friendly Thursday challenger usually drops a book about a specific phobia. Chronophobia is the fear of passing time and chronomentrophobia is the fear of clocks and watches- both of which have been mentioned previously by people

I am just going to keep spam clicking on him =p

rips hair out

I guess we'll just have to make a list of things to try every day for a while or something, until one of them works...

The only thing I can think of that will work is making sure it's nothing that worked on previous challengers.... so that might be the only solid hint we have.

[Spoiler] I tried wearing a gnome item and buying from shop. Nope I tried wearing dwarf items and buying from shop. Nope. I tried the chemistry items in inventory and wearing a rune item. Nope. [/Spoiler]

Being Grumpy was a dwarf from Snow White. He’s might be afraid of vertically-challenged people. Maybe babies or children.

this would've been hilarious

Agreed. ^_^