Replies

Nov 4, 2015 10 years ago Official
Mary
has some fries to go with that shake
User Avatar
Wattlebird

Quote by Elune
If the goal was to slow down and intruder, shouldn&;t they have a magical alert system that could tell teachers when someone broke through? Then, they could have interceded.

Excellent point! I hadn't thought about that. Otherwise they'd have to have someone check the room every so often. Speaking of which, do we think that Quirrell left some of the potion in the bottle before going through the flames? Wouldn't have drinking the whole thing have been better? Or do we think it refilled itself? If it refilled itself, then wouldn't it have been smart for Hermione to wait for it to refill, then go through and help Harry?

Unrelated note and going back to the beginning of the book... Why isn't there a disguised witch or wizard helping muggleborns onto the platform? Or do we think not telling Harry how to get onto the platform was just an oversight by Hagrid and they usually make sure to tell them how to get to the train?

Nov 5, 2015 10 years ago
poppet
User Avatar

I don't think the bottles would refill themselves because a break-in past that layer of protection would have been a huge deal. Going off of that thought, makes a great point regarding the oversight in leaving out an alarm system.

I think Muggle families with children accepted into Hogwarts are briefed about the platform, like the Granger and Evans parents for example. Hagrid seems like the type of person to forget about a travel detail like that.

Please log in to reply to this topic.