I would quit if anything happened to my pets, the same way people with 15K clothes in their wardrobe would probably quit if wardrobe was suddenly limited to 100 items

Ah-Dol hands down. He's my strongest battle pet. He was the second pet I created but the first I decided to start training. He's gone through like 4/5 name changes. Thankfully this name is sticking. lol

I'd be sad to lose the others, specially the two based off my real life cats, but somehow I think I'd feel less burdened down.

Glamourella because it is my first pet and I only have two pets anyways so I would be alright ;p

Dexter, since he's the first pet I created and I put everything into him - books, training, food, etc. :)

I'd choose Nibs :) She's my first pet, absolute favorite, matches my username, and I read her books + train her over my other pets already. I'd just hope to find my other pets loving homes ^^

Haha I owned Luce for years until I got a hold of Light.

...And seriously. I WOULD quit. Though, if I had to, you'd have to pry Mary from my cold dead pixel hands. I'm attached to my characters and my fandom pets, yes, but Mary is my mom's name and there's no one in my life more important to me.

Oh gosh, I have no idea who I'd choose. It's between Magnalia and Lizzabeth. Lizzabeth is my dream pet and has the best name but Magnalia is the most trained and I've spent time reading her books.

None of them have characters or stories yet but I suppose Lizzabeth is the only one I would want to develop that for and I could read books to her and train her to the same level, it's not like Magnalia's really that highly trained.

Haha, I'm definitely also in the 'would quit' boat! Pets are my priority on Subeta.

I'd pretty much definitely keep Halden, because he's my battle pet and I'm petty like that, but to be honest I'm not sure that he'd stay a reborn mortiking -- I'd probably be constantly renaming, morphing, and recoloring him!

I'd definitely pick Thief. He's my absolute baby. I'd definitely be sad over losing Garrus' stats, though. :P

Yeah, there's just no way I could ever choose just one of my pets. They are all special and dear to me and I've put SO much into all of them, not just one of them. So I would be highly upset and I'd quit XD. I mean, seriously, there's no way I could be happy with just one of my dream pets. Nope, wouldn't happen, sorry! Snuggles all my babies.

I have only pet (Clint) at the moment so the choice is really easy for me haha.

God damn. I think if that were actually a thing the site would tank. It'd be dead within a week.

Hypothetically speaking, I think I'd have to keep Lethallan because I'd have plenty to work on with her story, but it wouldn't be the same if I didn't have her companion pet. ; A ; IT'S LIKE CHOOSING A FAVORITE MOVIE OR TV SHOW.

I'd definitely be mad as hell though. I've spent too much on this site, including 7 extra pet slots, CW's for TCs, CS items for TCs, Multi-compartment keepsake boxes, name changes, potions...etc. to take that lightly. I think Keith would probably end up with an egged house and slashed tires, at the very least.

Oh god. THAT'S A HORRIBLE THING TO SAY. I'm only at 13k wearables but I'd quit for that reason as well. I think I've got that many CW's alone in my wardrobe, or close to it (100, not 15k obviously) I'd riot.

I know the OP said "assuming you don't quit" but really if I could only have one pet here I would go back to neopets. At least I would have 4 there. 😳

I would rage quit for sure xD. But if I have to pick one at the moment, I'd probably swap Schwarz and Viking's name, and keep Viking.

Midnight, no question. I love my pets but she's my baby. aha

I purposefully placed myself in that situation two years ago. I made a silly vow that I would only have one pet (obviously, one look at my page would show how that turned out).

But, if I absolutely had to, I would pick my Celinox, Taeru. He was the first pet I adopted on Subeta.

nicholas, omfg my most prized virtual possession.

Fringie, without a doubt.

This would be terrible! But I would choose Claude Glass. He's my first pet, so I have to keep him.