what if the staff decided to do some population control and you could only keep one of your pets? assuming the riots failed and you had to live with the rule because you couldn't bring yourself to quit, who would you keep? (+200 points if you manage to pick one single pet with no or's.)
in my case, i'd stick with Luce! he's got my favorite name, favorite pet & color combo, and even though he's got no visible character development on his profile, i do have a character for him whom i love.
I'd probably pick my pet Holophonor. I spoil it with books, stats, food, and everything anyway so.

Thracian. Absolutely no doubt. He was my first pet, he's capped and he's my baby. I would miss Kairi though. Just cause her name's so pretty.
Hmm... probably VCR, I love their name and they're really cute! Or Snipes, I make him read All The Books so he's pretty special too. I'd miss all of my other pets a ton tho tbh..
Aariston is my baby and I couldn't say goodbye to him. Tho I'd probably make a mock-up "profile" on my own website and just pretend to have all my pets again :P But yes, Aariston I've had for years, he isn't going anywhere.
What kind of horrible world would that be?! D: I'd keep Punkin for emotional attachment to the name but mourn all the work and luff I gave my other babies. ;-;
They/ThemI would likely quit the site in all honesty if such a rule was implemented. x: I seriously put too much into my pets here to not consider quitting so...
[edit] You got a forum point while making a post! Check out the shop here!
Do I win?
I would swap Prometheus' name over to Poseidon's ID and keep him. Losing Spock and Viracocha would kill me though. x___X
That would be so horrible I'd be tempted to quit haha
But...if pushed, I would keep Helix. But losing all my low id pets would make me cry. Every day xD
Zori. First pet, so it'd have to be that one.
But omg I'd be so upset.
I'd stick with my first pet, Fartsie. It's my battle, gourmand and everything else pet. (I'd be upset tho, omg.)
I really love all the names I have here, but would probably pick Turisas and change his name to Sepultura, 'cause that's my favorite band. Lost Korpiklaani and Alestorm would make me wanna die, though.
Cleared by staff. Width may not exceed 450 pixels.
I would without a shadow of a doubt, quit. And I'd be a far richer woman for it, too xD
I have played the "if you could keep ten" game though, and that one was hard but manageable. One though, naw.
100% I would quit. Not even in a parallel universe I could force myself to stay. But if I'd be that crazy that I'd stay and I should pick one of my Pets I might be tempted to keep Rusty Anonymous. :/ And of course I'd want a refund for my bought Pet slots because yeah...
But basically there is absolutely no chance I'd stay here if there was a "only 1 Pet" rule.
If that rule would become rality I would quit. Cause I love all of my pets and I allready did put a lot of work and time in most of them. So being forced to only keep one would piss me off like hell and I woud say "Good bye Subeta."
Yes even sizing down to ten is nearly not managable for me.. I really would be heartbroken, if I had to give nearly 20 of mine away only to keep ten.
Gallows Art (c) by Charlie.
My art can be found HERE
I'd have to go with Chili since I wanted her name since the day I joined the site. But I feel like I'd quit, too. Not only would I be upset with the "one pet" rule, I just would run out of stuff to do since working on my pets is what I like to do the most here lol.
[edit] You got a forum point while making a post! Check out the shop here!
Yuuuuush.
I'd probably quit/go extremely inactive too, but I'd keep Anna. She was a pet that was owned (or, rather was a name owned by, I guess), as well as the name of, a friend on subeta who passed away a few years back in late 2012. So, Anna is pretty special to me. A lot of my pets are but Anna is the most important in that regard.
This would be so cruel D; I'd keep Illy though since I've poured billions into boosting and reading books to her, Plus she was the first pet I created. I only ever meant to create 1 anyway. But ended up with 15 D; lol