I ruined it on my first try, but I can see that this may become addictive...! 
'Nice new game!
Oh no! The potion is ruined!
However, your help is appreciated, so here's a little something for you:
Noctou
Your score this time was: 2
Your total score is now: 2
Thank you for playing!
You may play again in 1 hour.
I ruined it!
But I got 64 points and a dawn chai plushie!
Cool!
I like this game!
Oh no! The potion is ruined!
However, your help is appreciated, so here's a little something for you:
Cheese and onion filler
Your score this time was: 2
Your total score is now: 26
Thank you for playing!
You may play again in 1 hour.
I have the first one in Subeta. o.0;
Field Donadak Plushie
Your score this time was: 512
Your total score is now: 516
..
Wee. 
cool game hope i get into the highsoures table
and hopefully get a potion
potions, potions, potions
groans I was able to choose nine times.. before, i suddenly find myself repaying the 500sP...dies and twitches for hours glitch?
It's so funnn..x3 -zombiefied- I got a cool tophat. xD
oow brew making just in time for halloween
this game is kool, already got like 4 items
you get to keep picking items, as long as you don't ruined the potion or the game is over
is there still a once per hour limit? Cause it let me play a few times in the last minute and I was wondering if I was allowed to play more than once an hour. I figured if it lets me play it's fine, but I am asking just in case. Thanks
However, your help is appreciated, so here's a little something for you:
Sun Swampie Beanbag
Your score this time was: 8
Your total score is now: 12
This is FuNn.
O.o; I don't get it XD; I thought we actually had to buy the item then click it XD smacks forehead
Hahaha. Whee! I have no idea why this is so fun.
Very fun, ruined it on first go with a Telenine Bouncy Ball.
Oh and, "magical" is missing the "c" on the opening ^^
great game!!! I love it.... actually have played it since i woke up xD lmao
ok so dont understand this game.. have got to play 2 x and only got 2 pts.. how do people already have over 4k in high scores..
LOVE this game
This very cool!!! Kudos whomever dreamed this one up!!
to
Ghostly Voodoo Plushie for the Stacey! ^__^ I like this game
This is evilly addictive! I love it
OK, who's responsible for this new game??? Tiles is still my fave, but this is funny.
..just as addictive as pushing a button, but uses more brainpower.. & less points...two thumbs up
GOOD JOB!
Sweet game. Obviously all chance like the krypts but better prizes.
cooll game i got 16 on first go
Hahaha oh I like this. I ruined the potion with a sooki beanbag and got 8points/Field Otter Beanbag, but oooo me likey... ^-^
yay i love it ^^ (i ruined it ^^) but i love it points 4 total 4
must play again...
oboy fun random things
oh that is soooo cool xP ruined the potion tho
darn! interesting game
Dusk Swampie Plushie
Your score this time was: 8
Your total score is now: 12
Ruined on the first go. 2 points and a cream covered orange... woot! waits for the next hour
I ruined it on the first shot, LOL, stupid paintbrushes.
Oh no! The potion is ruined!
However, your help is appreciated, so here's a little something for you:
Sun Dragon Beanbag
Your score this time was: 64
Your total score is now: 72
my new favourite game lol
I ruined it with a bloodred easter egg shell
fun game though
I ruined it with a snooki pillow case 
(will try again later) that thing is going to be adictive)
Ohhh, awesome! ^__^ I got a Dusk Dragon Plushie, and I ruined it with a Love Snowball. It was simmering peacefully, I thought a little Love would make it better. ;.;
However, your help is appreciated, so here's a little something for you:
Sun Swampie Lamp
Your score this time was: 8
Your total score is now: 8
Thank you for playing!
You may play again in 1 hour.
Hmm, it's a fun little game. I'll have to try it again.
So basically it's a lucky and chance game?
I wonder what you get if get the potion right...
Ooh, I ruined it with a sooki beanbag. I used it because it worked the frist time. Oh well. I got a smiley lemon.
I had to choose from 5 Healing Potions and took the yellow one (10HP) and ruined the Potion too.
WAH Now I have to wait ONE HOUR (so long 
) to play again...
Oh no! The potion is ruined!
However, your help is appreciated, so here's a little something for you:
Candy Apple Kora Pop
Your score this time was: 4
Your total score is now: 4
Thank you for playing!
You may play again in 1 hour.
neat!!!
I ruined the potion with a feli doll e__e. Oh well, got a peppermint at least. waves it about
Aw, I had to pick some essence of Keith so I picked his clothes but I ruined the potion XD
Lilax Kanis Plushie...
I had to choose from 5 snowballs aswell caly and I picked the love one and ruined the potion. Got a vortex book lol.
i ruined the potion on the first round and got a kumos day figurine xD
I ruined the potion with a black kerubi tail ;-;
I got an "All about Sports" for helping.
Yay.
Cool game xD I liked the Hikei part 8D