Rumor has it a rather shy shark has been spotted while fishing! This rumor has yet to be confirmed, though, because it seems this shark is quite rare.

Temictzin hoped this bait would help catch the shyshark, but it had no effect. You can get your own shyshark bait by completing the achievement Shark Bait!

The items required for this achievement can be found by fishing or visiting the Underground Springs.

[I]Update: For those curious about the item being dual use (wearable/food), it will be added to a future achievement so you will technically be able to get two! You'll have to wait for our pirate friends.