To me, this is perfect. Love it.
I love Charlies so I'm happy to see them get a revamp :D Love that cocked eyebrow, and the blue eyes on the Arid Charlie!
So much better, great revamp!
Awesome! I have a couple charlies, so I'm super happy about this.
they're cute but the pose and the facial expression just remind me of Scrappy Doo from the live action movies
Really digging the new wings. Lilac and Twilight are my favorite of this batch.
Honestly, I'm a little sad that the wart is gone, but there is just no losing here. I love the original, the proposed and the final revamp. <3 All the charlies, all the mischief, all the love! The artists around here (staff and not) are ridiculously fantastic. I'm full of respect and envy for you all! D:
They look really cute to me, nicely done
I want an army
Niiiiiiiiiiiiice. My only nitpick is that the purpleish red on the arid one looks a bit dark for an arid pet? But otherwise, I like these a lot.
The wings and the size of the head are ON POINT. And getting rid of the wart a brilliant move. Thanks for listening to our feedback, these are just amazing!
Great job artists!!!
sooooooooooo much better. welcome to 2016 charlies ;P
He has wings now! Before, they were a couple of thick flesh and skin lol
Wow, they actually look really badass now!
i've never really wanted a charlie until now, but WOW! i love the more real-looking wings!
I really love the new wings!
This is an excellent revamp. I'm really liking the new silver guy.
Wow! They look really awesome, and it was so, so needed!
Oooooo much love for this revamp! May have to get one of them now, if I can find a fitting character! :D
Wow, they look fantastic. And I love the wings on the final version, versus the proposed. The wings are just so much better. I never liked the Charlie before, but I do like how it looks now. Damnit, Subeta is turning into Pokemon, and I need more pet slots...
Oh, I like those wing. Glad they got changed as well.
Oh my gosh this revamp is FABULOUS. Such an improvement without losing the snarky attitude ;)
Ok that arid is suddenly my favorite Charlie
soooo much better!!
I can't wait to see more of the.. darker colours revamped (bloodred, etc [if they do em]). Might have to change my mind about what species my Conjurer is, even after all that hard work zapping! :D
Such an improvement!
I liked the mouth and anatomy better before. But it seems many people like the revamp so that's good!
Different strokes for different folks. :P
Proposed vs Finished
Yeah absolutely, this revamp actually almost makes me want one! They really remind me of a friend of mine. Now we just need revamps for all of it's special colors since that wing design is now different (but amazing). Can't wait to see those, hopefully the special colors won't take as long to get some love as the Serpenths did! Again, great job artists! Thanks for the hard work to keep our artwork stunning. <3
Never really been a charlie fan but these revamps are pretty good. Their expressions and wings are very well done! So far the cherry and lilac are my favourite/
I love them. I never liked them before, but now I need a few.
I never liked them to being with, but feel they're worse now. But I'm not a Charlie owner, so yay for those of you who are happy.
THIS IS SO BEAUTIFUL ;O;
Just for comparison. I like the revamp!
Wow, this is a solid revamp! I really like it!
The revamp is top notch, and the wings are nice and tattered. On another note...
hides candy
Wow this looks amazing! I was just talking to a friend about how these and a handful of other pets severely needed updated art. Glad one got knocked off the list! Good job! They really look evil and devious even more than before and that is just perfect for them. <3
ah! The silver one looks like a gargoyle; I love it!
Oh yes, it looks os great.. so evily and mean needs to make one
I love this update so much, especially the Arid one. I totally need one ❤
Preferred the bulky look of the old version but otherwise very nice.
omg the little devil is so cute!!
I LOVE THE NEW WINGS!!!
Wow looks pretty awesome! Good job!!!
So many charlies in one place unnerves me a little. Look at them all plotting. They're going to steal all of my candy.
This might be the best revamp thus far! :D Looks fantastic!
Oh yay, that wing looks so much better than the last version! Looks great!
Really nice update! They turned out great! c: Happy to see more Silver, Cherry and Aqua pets as well!
Heh heh, that grin is very mischievous..... ;)