Not sure what the parameters for Melody's wishlist peek is but today she has suggested two cws. now while I like to be generous this is asking a bit too much & means I am seeing two less suggestions.

Today Mistery Melody did not make the gift exchange at midnight, like in december 12. On a nothe, I can see some items labeled as "1 in the pool" but I don't know it that is intentional or not, since, it would be a little hint to not repeat gifts :O

edit I forgot e can upload images now! Here is a screenshot for better showing what's up, this is supossed to be yesterday round.

Just want to reiterate that Mystery Melody also did not do the gift exchange at midnight for me either.

I also have the same issue of seeing an item say "1 in the pool" which hasn't happened before.

Mysterious Melody did not distribute the items today.

Mine also did not distribute gifts and the suggested gifts are now different than they were yesterday.

Same here.

I'm still having the same only 4 wishlist peek items. But they always used to rotate after a while, did they not? At least I know I saw different ones along the day.

Chiming in to say, Mysterious Melody didn't distribute items for my group either.

The "1 in Pool" though as far as I am aware is by design. I saw it mentioned in the changelog that this feature was added to reduce the probability of duplicate items in the pool. A very helpful addition in my opinion.

Melody must still be asleep, for none of my items were distributed either!

Melody hasn’t disturbed any items but new wishlist items are showing up.

just dropping in to mention that my group is still the same, no distribution of items and cant go into a new pool

Just checked on my Mysterious Melody poll again...items still haven't been distributed since last night.

So we skipped a day, never mind.

One didn't contribute at all, even though he/she had 2 days of time. One only threw in very cheap items. o.k., that happens.

Yet what I think is sad is, that even Melody no longer chooses anything from our wishlists :-(

The Wishlist thing might actually be random I'm thinking? Or perhaps you just had bad luck .

Out of the six items I received (since there were only 19 total contributions due to some people not putting in the full five) four of them were WL items.

We did end up skipping a day so IDK what was up with that, but I ended up making out pretty well with WL items this go round.

Today I received almost only wishlist items happy dancing - even though we had 1 partner, that didn't give anything.

Fancy, it's almost always the last one joining, that doesn't contribute.

Seconded. Furthermore, Melody is quoting the shop price for these CWs in sP, when the shop price is actually in CSC.

[edit]12/28/2025: Not sure if this is intended behavior or not, but Melody bought 0 items for the group I was in yesterday/this morning.

Just came to see if anyone else had experienced this and I see that had the same issue. Melody apparently lost her giving spirit and added nothing to the pool this time for my group either.

Melody didn't give my group anything today.

We also didn't receive anything from Melody (and on top we again had one non-contributor in the group)

Does she think, Luminaire is over?

Also nobody in charge has yet answered regarding the missing achievement prize... :-(

Melody didn't added to our group this past round, and despite everyone contributed I only got 3 items out of a pool of 15