So far I'm really enjoying this change!

There goes more of my vintage collection value XD I respect the transparency, thanks for all you do and hope you and the team have a great Holiday season.

I think this is a great change, though I do have a question. I cant seem to find a directory of daily Melody gifts. For example, I missed yesterday and have no idea if I missed out on a new item or not...does anyone know if a thread was started for new items?

If you check out subetalodge, it should have a running list of all the new items from Melody, as well as lists for the older Melody items

I hope we still get a new coal item this year, I always love seeing what we get on 12/22

We're over halfway through this event, and I've found this system to be lacking. I've picked the same two years for Melody's gifts in hopes of getting certain items, and I've found myself getting duplicates of "worthless" items. Those items become even more worthless through this system. I would prefer committing to one past year and getting all the gifts for that year over this randomized system that results in multiples of the same worthless item.

If we could choose one or two specific items on the 25th from the entire Melody item pool, that would somewhat lessen the blow. But as of right now, it doesn't even have the true feel of Melody's Cottage when you get the same items repeatedly. That simply doesn't happen in other years, as you get unique items each day. I'm pretty disappointed in my visits to Melody's Cottage for 2025.

Wait a minute garden revamp? Oooh this is wonderful, I haven't been on much this year but thank you for tagging me so much! <3 I could hug you!!