You Win:

Subetan Fish Hook

How did you manage to get that far away from the perfect fishing spot?

Blue Tackle Box

You were nowhere near it!

You Win: Vermilion Rockfish

You Win:

Depressed Worm

If you had just gotten a little closer!

Euphoric Worm

If you had just gotten a little closer!

You Win:

Bagged Goldfish

If you had just gotten a little closer!

Bekko Koi

You were nowhere near it!

You Win:

Stixx

If you had just gotten a little closer!

Evish

You were nowhere near it!

You Win:

Grape Jellyfish

You were so close!

You Win: Shyshark

You were so close!

I can't find anything on these forums!!!

You Win:

Anglerfish

You were nowhere near it!

I can't find a Shyshark in the sea :(

It's become my favorite catch. It's so darn cute! Let me know if you want one of mine, but I suspect you want to catch your own (that's what I prefer doing.) I still haven't found two items via fishing, and I'm beginning to think they have been retired from the bunch. One of these days I'll ask about them.

White Tackle Box

You were nowhere near it!

Yes you're right, it'll make eventually finding my own all the more special!

You Win:

Purple Bobber

You were nowhere near it!

You Win: Shrimpy Shrimpy

You were so close!

You Win:

Anglerfish

You were nowhere near it!

Tri Jaw Fish

If you had just gotten a little closer!

You Win:

Sour Apple Jellyfish

You were so close!

Bagged Swordtail Fish

You were so close!