Hoi :D Welcome to Subeta!

I haven't played with my pets in forever, but I do believe toys are single use. If I recall correctly, to keep your pets happy you can simply equip a minion (a mini pet) to your pet, and your pet should stay at 9/10 happiness

You can obtain minions from places like here

Hope that helps!

Useful Links:

What to do on Subeta? FAQ Useful general information for newbies Customise your dashboard Useful Custom CSS Builder Shoutbox (live chat) / Discord Finding friends (Chit Chat) SubetaLodge (Offsite item database, pet colours etc.) Current Event: Keel Hauliday