Take it!!

3 legged dog

Take it

A Monster energy drink

Leave it

iPad with a cracked screen

Leave it

A chocolate birthday cake

leave it

tricycle

Leave it..I'd have no use for it

Cold glass of lemonade

take it

a brand new car but without tires

Leave it. I wouldn't want to buy tires for it / put money into it because it may not be the kind of car I like.

An Amazon Kindle

leave it (I prefer audible for "reading")

used makeup

Leave it

A bottle of ibuprofen

take it

a motorcycle

Take it

A turntable record player

Take it

A Bearded Dragon

Take it

A new set of cookware

Take it!

A supposedly haunted music box.

Take it...could be interesting o_o

A new Samsung Galaxy S20

Take it - it is time for a new phone

A slice of strawberry shortcake

Oooooh take it!! I haven't had that in so long.

A cup of hot black coffee ( any brand / bean / type but no additives - only black )

Take the coffee, would you take....

a cat?

Take it

A potion that makes you immortal - but only enough for you