[item2=Pink Bobber]

You were nowhere near it!

You Win: [item2=Sour Apple Jellyfish] You were so close!

Rean

If you had just gotten a little closer!

Swirling Ocean Bead

You were nowhere near it!

You Win: Black Tackle Box

You were nowhere near it!

[item2=Green Tackle Box]

You were nowhere near it!

Strawberry Jellyfish

You were so close!

Black Tackle Box

You were nowhere near it!

Broken Worm

If you had just gotten a little closer!

[item2=Subetan Fish Hook]

How did you manage to get that far away from the perfect fishing spot?

You Win: [item2=Evish]

You were nowhere near it!

[item2=merdra]

If you had just gotten a little closer!

Tabby Catfish

You were nowhere near it!

[item2=Sanke Koi]

If you had just gotten a little closer!

Old Boot

How did you manage to get that far away from the perfect fishing spot?

[item2=Silver Tackle]

How did you manage to get that far away from the treasure?

You Win: Baby Creature

How did you manage to get that far away from the treasure?

You Win: [item2=Carrot Fish] You were so close!

(I also got the "Fishing Expert" achievement for this)

Ogon Koi

You were nowhere near it!

[item2=Fish Bones]

How did you manage to get that far away from the perfect fishing spot?