I've had no trouble getting the darks and winds -- an average of a couple dozen each type. Freezers are about a third of rate.
My smallest Pet fought Tide 206 times so far and only got 3 Freezing Cabochon Crystals out of those 106 battles.
I'm rather carrying on for the amulets and tomes.
Crap, I forgot to account for General Error with the Freezing Marquise Crystals.
So I actually got 115 crystals out of 938 total items, which is 12.3%. The expected rate drop rate is 17.2% if they were given out evenly.
An account search says I have 71. With another 10 modded in weapons and another 10 max that I've given away, we can assume that's 91 or fewer. I'm too lazy to figure out how many battles I've done w/each pet that count, but I wouldn't be surprised if my drop rate is similar to what you've seen. It does feel high though. I suppose because we have to wade through so many battles to get to the good loot. lol
EDIT:
I did 100 extra battles against Vulty and got:
Wind Defense Cabochon Crystal x7
Wind Cabochon Crystal x8
Dark Magma Potion x85
and 34 Medium BC tokens
So the % for each is easy to calculate. Granted, it is a small sample size -- but the drop rates are disappointing since you have to do 100 battles to get within the range of a CHANCE of crystal drops. I don't count the 100th battle since that drop is set. Seven and eight percent chance against a medium foe? Bummin'...
Wind Moonstone Crystal Wind Moonstone Defense Crystal Obtained by defeating Johannes 75 times with the same pet in the Battle Coliseum.
Earth Brilliant Crystal Earth Defense Brilliant Crystal Obtained by defeating Gunter 50 times with the same pet in the Battle Coliseum.
Earth Marquise Crystal Earth Defense Marquise Crystal Obtained by defeating Batista 35 times with the same pet in the Battle Coliseum.
Fire Marquise Crystal Fire Defense Marquise Crystal Obtained by defeating Mathis 35 times with the same pet in the Battle Coliseum.
Water Marquise Crystal Water Defense Marquise Crystal Obtained by defeating Batista 35 times with the same pet in the Battle Coliseum.
You are a rockstar, thank you for the info and the handy copy/paste-able descriptions! I was able to update from my phone xD
No rewards except XP from the Pirate Crew :-(
You're welcome! And I have another one for you:
Light Brilliant Crystal Light Defense Brilliant Crystal Obtained by defeating Evil Morty 50 times with the same pet in the Battle Coliseum.
I have no idea if Lukien drops anything. He's too difficult to get that far :P
Thank you for the update! I very much appreciate you letting me know! I'd have replied sooner but it's been a long week (I've been sick and working still gah). They're adjusted on SL to reflect the new challenger drop!
Aww, I hope you're feeling better!
From Som: Wind Cabochon Crystal Wind Defense Cabochon Crystal Obtained by defeating Som 100 times with the same pet in the Battle Coliseum.
Got those updated, thank you!
I am a little confused. If I mod a weapon with four Freezing Marquise or Freezing Brilliant Crystals, will I have a 12% chance of freezing?
What would one suggest I mod The Ether with? I would think the freezing crystals, but is there something else I should do?
If you were to use four, the odds of any of the crystals causing a freeze on any one turn is calculated like so: 1 - (0.97 * 0.97 * 0.97 * 0.97) = 1 - (0.885) = 0.115 = 11.5%
The most popular crystals are:
However, which ones you should equip depends on your opponent. If you are trying to prevent yourself from being frozen, Parched Baguette Crystal is the best. Blessing of Natural Armor Tear Crystal will prevent freezing and stealing, but for a fewer amount of turns. Singed Baguette Crystal and Critical Strike Tear Crystal are best for inflicting the maximum amount of damage that you can.
If you prefer freezing crystals, then it's fine to use those too, I just personally don't and opt for freezing scrolls like Shriek of Despair because I find they are more reliable.
Thank you for your reply. Are there any other scrolls, like that? I made a 'Cold Blast', but it seems to freeze much less often than 71%.. Would you happen to know how many times you have to beat the Night Lady, before you get 'Shriek of Despair', or is it random?
Shriek of Despair is a random drop.
It's random. There's about a 10% chance of her dropping one after each win.
-Psycho Smashers are the next best and you can get two from defeating General Error 10 and 50 times. -Strong Stomp is a new one that can be obtained from defeating Gelatin Stomper whenever we have another Gelatin War. -Gale Force is available in the Battle Shop. I don't think it freezes quite as much as the other three. -Cold Blast is one you already mentioned and you can get one per pet if they're strong enough. -There is also Perilous Whirlpool, which has a low chance to freeze, but it's cheap to make yourself at the Secluded Shrine and doesn't take up that much AP.
If you want to look into some infinite use freezing scrolls, Unstable Fairy, Assassin, and Gelaspell Scroll are all pretty good.
I will look at those, thank you.
You Won! You have defeated Nightlady 2 times!
You won a(n) Extremely Hard token to use in the battle shop!
Nightlady drops:
Tome of Darkness Shriek of Despair Scroll Fresh Pumpkin You earned 90000 sP for beating Nightlady!
PrinceOfEgypt earned 3228 EXP Points!
It's that time of the month again :P
Earth Eye of Royalty Crystal Earth Defense Eye of Royalty Crystal Magma Eye of Royalty Crystal Magma Defense Eye of Royalty Crystal Obtained by defeating Kain 25 times with the same pet in the Battle Coliseum.