I missed the wishing shrub the first time so I wish I could have participated. For that reason alone I would love to see it come back at least once so those who missed it could participate.

I didn't like the shrub. To me it's no different than a wish list or Mysterious Melody.

I somehow also missed this... haha XD

But it sounds kinda fun. I think I'd be for it.

Unpopular opinion but I didn't like the shrub and I participated maybe twice. It was nearly impossible to fullfill wishes and my cheap wishes were quickly claimed (ofc). I remember how many argo liners were requested ... and all those CSC cards, godly weapons and such. If it were to be brought back, there would need some serious tweaking and whatnot. I can't see myself enjoying such activities knowing it's going to be utterly insane and ridiculous. I already have Luminaire to be insane and ridic'.

lol. completely forgot about this. honestly wasnt the biggest fan of itr.

I think if they bring it back, it has to have more rules/restrictions. And bring it only for an event/occasions.

I LOVED the wishing shrub! I had completely forgotten about it! I'd love to see it back. <3

Blocking out certain rarities definitely seems like it would be a must-do (and the easiest way to filter out impossible wishes, imo?) if it were to make a return. I can't think of a better way to better regulate the amount of wishes available/up for claiming, though.

Maybe after x amount of hours having the shrub reset, and having 2 - 3 wishes per day instead of just one? Since if your wish isn't granted in, say, 3 - 5 hours, it's unlikely it'll be granted in 12 or 24. that way it avoids day/night user traffic changes being a large part of why some folks might not be able to get a wish in, if they're only able to be online at certain times rather than right at midnight reset.

The only way I'd like to see the wishing shrub come back is if it was handled kind of like a user-donated free shop - put a gift in, you get to take a gift out, and you don't know what you got until you open it.

It would probably end up being all junk but at least then we wouldn't end up with 13412394871234 blackheart/cash shop wishes and no way to fulfill those requests.

I hated the shrub.