Oh dang, this is hard.
I love, love, LOVE Jollins. And Legeicas. Probably my two fave species.
Any pet in Scribble form is fantastic for me. I am also partial to the experiments as well.
I have a lot of Kumos, but I reallllllyyy like Jollins. Otters are also one of my favorite animals, so I really like the sweetheart Ontra, just so cute. <3
When I first joined the site I fell for Priggles because they remind me of my irl cat. She is very... round. She is very much like a woodland animal. It helps that not many people seem that into Priggles, it makes me feel even more proud and defensive of them! My Priggle was my only pet for a long time until I wooed a Zentu this weekend, and I'm feeling weird about having split attachments, lol!
I really like the experiment pets... Does that count? They make up 1/4 of my pets at the moment...
When I joined it was Charlies. Though I ended up with none at all for a while for reasons that are unknown to me at all. Now I have only one... though I do love the species.
I'm probably more obsessed with the color Nightmare. I also have a few Graveyard Pets but besides a few I'm going to color them in Nightmare as well one day. xD
I currently have nine Donadaks, with two more on the way once I get the right potions for them. I fell in love with 'em after getting my Sweetheart one and now I'm committed to coming as close to a full set of the 'fancier' colors of 'em as I can with my limited pet slots.