Part of me is worried that it's tied to pets still, somehow. I always use Folklore for battling, and maybe by trying to battle the troll and constantly losing/forfeiting, it drops my chance of winning, regardless of weapon...

all my pages tested and no joy What are the more expensive weapons we need to try? do we have a list

All those weapons have been tested in this thread c: Thank you for testing page 14!

I'm compounding a list in the main post of unchecked weapons, if you're interested in seeing what else needs testing ^_^

T4 has only 6 pages in SubetaLodge's database, and T5 is 5 pages. From the looks of the first page of each though, they all look expensive :x

I can test the Snow Globe Staff of Winter and the bottled dark matter.

I have the Boots of Deathward, I'll check them out.

I can test these Cherry Bombs Eternal Boots of Deathward Bottled Dark Matter Snow Globe Staff of Winter

My two pages are done - no luck, I'm afraid.

Notes: -Kumos Scythe was not tested (I don't have a Kumos so I can't test) -Equippables were not tested (throwing vials/pylonics) -Single use items were tested (subetaballs)

Not the Boots of Deathward.

I have tested the Kumos Scythe.

I really hope not. Multiple people have managed to win against him when the weapon was found. They would all have to have low losses in order for that to work ^_^' And it would be extremely unfair to hard workers like ourselves

No luck with pages 17 and 20. Looks like we're going to have to start looking at higher tiers, let's hope it's a more popular weapon.

I can test Cruel Lawnmower of Slaying as well, I forgot I had all my minions in that minion zoo/battle thingy.

No luck with those weapons I posted above but I lost my Cherry Bombs :o opps

Oh crap! I hate that and they were expensive as well.

RESULTS: 26/33 pages tested: That's about 78% of all T1 and T2 weapons tested in the span of 1 hour :x I don't think the staff would be cruel enough to have the weapon change every hour, so I think it's just stuck at one higher tiered weapon we haven't tested yet.

The higher the tier the less amount of weapons there are, which could explain why so far we've been lucky by the troll's choices in low tiered weapons (33 pages of T1-2 weapons, 10 pages of T3, 6 pages of T4, 5 pages of T5, etc.)

Please let me know if you guys are willing to test Tier 3 weapons! ^_^

yea I thought it was ok to use, I remember getting them ages ago too for my weapon gallery, I will have to re buy I think

I can test T3 weapons, I need a break though for my lunch haha

That's why I'm hesitant to use any breakable items. It makes me sick and they weren't even mine! Maybe they'll release them in the crystal shop or something. Ugg :(

I can take a page of tier 3

That's true.. ;) Hopefully we can find the next weapon soon!

, give me a page and I'll do it :)

Ok, I'm going to be recording people here who want to help with T3 weapons. I need to combine it with the people in the original battle thread because some of them already went to work on some T3 pages ^_^ Hang in tight, folks, I'll let you know what's going down soon!