you can just tell it :p

theres spoiler tabs for a reason

As it turns out, I can't! I beat him five times, and now my solution isn't working for me anymore, or for anyone else. :P The plot thickens.

I wasn't sure if the staff that put this together would appreciate me putting the solution up right away, is why I didn't post it. c: But, as it turns out, it was a moot point.

We're supposed to "out troll" him are there any troll weapons? (clubs maybe?) Has anyone tried the reflecting weapons? Are there any weapons that actually reflect damage back? (I looked through all the defensive weapons on subetalodge and couldn't find the word 'reflect' in any notes.) I have a feeling none of my pets will be able to win since he's set up past Prodigy... I mean, it could be in that difficulty simply for the puzzle of it... but the challenger difficulty usually coincides with tier ability, yeah? :/

Also, I googled 'out troll the troll' and there are plenty of sites to scrounge ideas for weapons/strategies that staff may have looked at. I'll be back to look into them more later, but I have to go get the car tire's changed/alignment/goodlordknowswhatelse. D:

Good luck all!

but which shield was it? now I'm curious :p

It was the Hikei Grooming Brush Shield. |D

The items are in the item directory now that someone has beat the bastard.

Now I'm off to find T1 shields.

Oh dear, and I took too long to post XD Congrats on the wins

The shields I've tried so far have been No luck..

are not working.

Is it really right direction? Maybe there's anther solution?

The shields I've tried so far with no luck....

didn't work! haha i thought it would all things considered.

these didn't work either....

He did not get distracted by eating either. Also tried some of the ones already mentioned.

I just tested the , , , , , and .

No luck.

I tried Plunger of Doom since the description said "N'er again shall your opponent mock you. For with this mighty toilet accessory, you transform into... The Toilet Avenger! -Dramatic music-" However, it doesn't work! :( Nor did the Grooming shield

Hmm... No good with these either

My losses just keep on stacking because I have to keep forfeiting xD I have no idea how to edge this guy!

I have tried:

this is getting annoying haha

all the shields according to subetalodge...