IS SARAH CANONICALLY AT LEAST A YEAR OLDER THAN AMY?

I mean, I am pretty sure she is. But, this is all we need.

Tell that to the Repurposed Bread Tag.

some people on staff like to keep the hope alive, apparently. I AM NOT ONE OF THEM.

WELL TOO BAD. LONG LIVE AMY.

why are you out to ruin my hopes and dreams specifically first you guys take amy and then you take my HOPE

NOBODY LIKED AMY WHEN SHE WAS ALIVE

grab the shotguns we're putting elsie and this theory to rest

"Amy

• NOT ELSIE"

SOB. There goes my favorite conspiracy theory plot hope. BRB drowning my hopes and dreams in Port Plunder.

This is great, though. Love how Alexander's missing whiskers are explained away and all the little bizarre friendships and habits are touched on.

SHE HAD HER WHOLE LIFE AHEAD OF HER!!!! SHE DESERVED SO MUCH BETTER AND I WILL FIGHT FOR HER

WE DID ALL WE COULD IN THIS PLOT BUT IN THE END SHE STILL DED.

maybe elsie is so adamantly not amy because amy is coming back as a zombie this year during zombietines day

pst

canIadoptCinthia

I'll still keep believing Elsie is Amy. Maybe Elsie "is not" Amy, because she can't remember who she is or she reconstructed her memories and became Elsie. You know, traumatic past and being a zombie and all. /forever clings to hope

it okay, i made enough points for the two of us

I really love lore in ANY game (I'm the nerd who sat for hours just listening to the nice gentleman narrate the Mass Effect codexes and has been devouring every bit of GW2 lore my friend gives me), so the NPC lists make me extra happy. I like learning little things about characters!

(Comically, I wasn't here for what happened to Amy, so imagine my surprise when I came back after a several-year hiatus to find out a new character was running those quests. There were probably visible question marks over my head before I looked up what happened.)

You've basically said my feels and thoughts on this matter. This is why you're the best. Elsie=Amy 5ever.

Damn straight. Amy 5ever /fistbump T___T (btw your av is fab) Maybe there will be some plot regarding this this year One can hope

NEVER GIVE UP HOPE! I'm actually hoping no plot on Elsie just because I'm sure they'll provide backstory to showcase how SHE IS NOT AMY since they so clearly want to state SHE IS NOT AMY. Even though we all know SHE IS AMY. grins

(ALSO TY. I smooshed her together because I'm way too excited for survival this year.)

I'm not too concerned about Amy/Elsie, but I will always believe that "Ricardo" is actually a petite young woman masquerading as a boy for reasons as yet unknown.