I don't know. I clicked on 5, saw the numbers, tried 1 and got it. At least I think it was 1.

Is it required to do a quentin quest?

shopkeeper at the beach shack. i'm however stuck trying to get her a "special seashell from the beach", bc seashell spotter keeps giving me items with seashell in the name and not actual seashells, lol. if you have any ideas, hmu.

after finishing quentin's part and talking to blake:

You mention that Quentin sent you and ask about the map items

Oh alright, I’ll help you. Yes, the Hustler has been here. At least, I saw him go in to the Crypts, but he wasn’t in for long. I don’t suppose you’ll have too much trouble in finding what you’re looking for.

Huh, I thought it would start with the first one? XD

What is the part before the beach shack?

Ok, got it on 6. It really must be random for everyone. Thanks for the help! And thank you too :)

Talking to Blake @ the Crypts:

You mention that Quentin sent you and ask about the map items

Oh alright, I’ll help you. Yes, the Hustler has been here. At least, I saw him go in to the Crypts, but he wasn’t in for long. I don’t suppose you’ll have too much trouble in finding what you’re looking for.

Buy something from Icy Goods.

After getting the mage's piece, he'll tell you to go somewhere pretty and recently discovered--go to Peka Glade. Esther will be there, super upset-only one person can calm her down. Go to Seedlings to talk to Emma. Go back to Peka Glade to pass on Emma's message, Esther will give you her piece and mention Gunter's goat.

Go to Veta, find Oatmeal, and try to feed him a worry. He'll spit it back out, click on the brewery to talk to Gunter and get his piece. He'll tell you that the Hustler was headed for the ocean.

Go to Delphi, talk to Lindsay at the Beach Shack. She'll want you to play Seashell Spotter until you get one of its unique items, then talk to her again to get her piece and a clue about dice.

Go to the carnival, win a game of Bluff to get that guy's piece. After that, I'm not sure what to do.

Seeing as you got past Blake...! Do you have to complete the Crypts, or do you just randomly find it in a room? Sorry if you already answered this for someone, but I tried reading through all the responses here before asking. :>

She won't take my Triton Shell, so idk what she wants

Bought something from Icy Goods but nothing happens :(

I found it (what appears to be) randomly, in the second room.

you get the piece when you walk through the first door, and then you must quit. i kept going until i got lost and didn't get a message, so i went back to the page i got the map piece and clicked 'quit', then got a message. :)

i'm not getting anything at the ice fields edit nvm i didnt go to the catapult -.-

- many thanks! :)

Lindsay wants one of the unique items the game gives out (one of these items, not the pauldron)

Thank you! I've got my timer set, so I'll be back at the hunt in an hour.

Anyone know what to do after playing Bluff?

EDIT: Ah, nvm, I went back to the Hustler and it looks like I found everything!

Quentin plz.. One extra quest today wouldn't hurt. I guess I'm stuck until tomorrow. Thanks for the guide.

Just Bluff left. Err, I hate this game lol

This has been fun though!