Skittles

Peanut butter taffy (mysteriously wrapped in black), or orange-flavored peanut-shaped meringue candy?

meringue candy

white or dark choc.?

dark chocolate yumm!!

potatoes mashed or baked?

Mashed all the way.

Green bean casserole or bacon brussel sprouts?

green bean casserole (not made with canned soup or canned beans though, ew)

taco bell or rubio's?

Taco Bell.

Cherry Limeade or Strawberry Lemonade?

Bleurgh. Your houseplants are going to get an unscheduled watering. A gag-face would be less likely with strawberry lemonade. (and lemonade is harder to smell when it's in potting mix) Let's pick that one.

Cherry cola or Vanilla cola?

Cherry Cola.

Brussel Sprouts or Cabbage?

brussel sprouts

pumpkin or peppermint?

Pumpkin.

Apple Turnover or Apple Pie?

Apple pie.

Fried chicken or roast chicken?

Roast chicken!!

Fried fish or baked?

Are fish sticks kinds pre-fried but you bake them? I just get them frozen instead of battering them myself. Baked I guess.

Lumpy cranberry sauce from fresh berries, or jellied puree in the shape of the can?

Lumpy Cranberry Sauce.

Steak and Eggs or Belgian Waffles?

Steak and eggs!

Cheesecake or pie?

Cheesecake!

Banana Pudding or Philly Cheesesteak?

banana pudding! 8D

jelly beans or sour patch kids?

Jellybeans. Not every flavor mind...

Pfefferneuse or Jam Thumbprints?

Jam thumbprints.

Alfredo or Spaghetti?

Spaghetti.

Tomato and Rice Soup or Cheddar Broccoli Soup?