Fish tacos

Grilled cheese sandwich or french toast?

Grilled cheese

Quesadilla or Albondigas?

Quesadilla.

Pumpkin Pie or Peach Cobbler?

pumpkin pie!

peanut butter or apple butter?

Apple butter

Ketchup or Mustard?

Mustard

BBQ sauce or Sweet n Sour sauce?

Sweet n Sour.

Raspberry or Blueberry?

Blueberry

Vegetable salad or fruit salad?

Vegetable salad. I don't really like mixing fruits.

Sweet potatoes or regular potatoes?

Regular potatoes.

Chicken strips or Fish sticks?

Fish Sticks

Tater Tots or Potato Salad?

Potato Salad

Key Lime or Pecan pie?

Key Lime.

Tiramisu or Baked Alaska?

Tiramisu!

Garlic bread or banana bread?

Oooh both really yummy. Banana bread by a thin sliver of velleity.

Zucchini Bread or Carrot Cake?

Carrot cake

Cheesecake or Birthday cake?

Cheesecake

Ice cream or chocolate?

Chocolate, though I wouldn't pass up chocolate ON ice cream, or chocolate flavored ice cream...

truffles (chocolate ones, not the mushrooms) or chocolate bars?

Truffles

Peanut brittle or Chocolate bar with crisped rice mixed in

Peanut Brittle.

Cherry Cheesecake or Peach Pie?