I think some people who go into rate threads are just looking for an ego boost. Maybe they just weren't happy because you didn't exactly hand it to them, haha~ Don't worry about it at all, your post was more than fine!

The only reason a person would make a rating thread is to get others to lick their balls a bit. Sry bebs, your tongue wasn't good enough.

It's one thing not to be able to take the heat, but in a kitchen you built? Lol.

thanks you guys, seriously, LMAO it's sad that i was legitimately worried i was being a total bitch because i try to be pretty honest and thorough with my rates since i want people to be the same for me and i guess they just didn't want to hear it.

Your critique was very good, constructive without being rude. I agree that the user seems to be butthurt because you didn't tell them their HA was perfect. It doesn't matter what the score you gave them was, whether it was 6/10 or 2/10 as long as you were being fair and constructive with your commentary.

To repeat what everyone else has said, your rating left nothing to be desired; in fact, I'd say it's really better than what most people get from rating threads these days, which is to say: actually useful. ;)

Ya. Give someone what they ask for, then find out that what they're asking for is not actually what they're angling at.

A sly demand for approval and ass-licking, disguised as a request for honest feedback.

At least you're not a softcock who caves into SHITE attempts of manipulating forced praise out of others for the gratification of your typical attention whore/narcissist/whatever.

Straight up honesty delivered in a polite and mature way; you should be proud of that, not made to feel guilty.

Look on the bright side; at least you're not one of them.

people like that are stupid, they want you to help them with their ha and then they say your too mean rolls eyes

I don't see how that's at all rude. In fact, compared to some of the critiques I've given, I'd say it was nice. If they're too immature to handle a politely given critique, then oh well, sucks for them.

That is definitely not rude. You're just giving constructive criticism. But some people really can't tolerate criticism. In that case, they should not post on those kinds of topics.