You Win: [Item=Fish Bones] Fish Bones

How did you manage to get that far away from the treasure?

Tilapia

If you had just gotten a little closer!

You Win: [Item=Tabby Catfish] Tabby Catfish

You were nowhere near it!

Ribbit

If you had just gotten a little closer!

You Win:

Bagged Guppy

If you had just gotten a little closer!

Pineapple Jellyfish

You were so close!

You Win: [Item=Cheap Fishing Pole] Cheap Fishing Pole

You were nowhere near it!

Sour Apple Jellyfish

You were so close!

You Win: [Item=Dripping Sea Lettuce] Dripping Sea Lettuce

If you had just gotten a little closer!

Green Bobber

You were nowhere near it!

You Win: [Item=Gulper Eel] Gulper Eel

You were so close!

Toad

You were nowhere near it!

You Win:

Tri Jaw Fish

If you had just gotten a little closer!

Anglerfish

You were nowhere near it!

You Win:

Dripping Sea Lettuce

If you had just gotten a little closer!

You Win: Cheap Fishing Pole

Baby Creature

How did you manage to get that far away from the perfect fishing spot?

You Win: You were nowhere near it!

Euphoric Worm

If you had just gotten a little closer!

You Win: Book Worm

If you had just gotten a little closer!