It's almost definitely, 100% random, but if there was just a keyword we needed to find to guarantee a cookie...

I think you misread my post - Finding the cookie is probably random, but if you throw in items with key words with guaranteed results, like items with the word "pie", then you will definitely not get a cookie.

You tossed your Rubber Mallarchy into the rift and a moment of calm is followed by a flash of red lightning, before the rift shoots out Were All Mad Here Sticker!

[item2=Were All Mad Here Sticker]

Skipped a few steps ahead in the thought process-- the thread tells you what to throw in for guaranteed results, so you know what NOT to throw in...but I was saying that while getting a cookie is certainly random, wouldn't it be great if we had a keyword to guarantee one?

Having a guaranteed key word would definitely make it easier, but it's not bad to have something to look forwards to/work on either

Hopefully the odds aren't too bad so everyone can get the amount of cookies they're after for their collection

It's the tempest cookie I'm more worried about n_n

You tossed your White Ruffled and Pleated Shirt into the rift and a moment of calm is followed by a flash of red lightning, before the rift shoots out nothing at all. Guess you lost that one.

You tossed your Llama Cookie into the rift and a moment of calm is followed by a flash of red lightning, before the rift shoots out nothing at all. Guess you lost that one.

You tossed your Cocoa-Blue Cupcake Choker into the rift and a moment of calm is followed by a flash of red lightning, before the rift shoots out Red Vest and Shirt!

[item2=Red Vest and Shirt]

Not today either

You tossed your Gray Longstockings into the rift and a moment of calm is followed by a flash of red lightning, before the rift shoots out Harpy Cloak!

You tossed your Purple Celestial Flask into the rift and a moment of calm is followed by a flash of red lightning, before the rift shoots out Blue Shrug!

You tossed your Kitty Fruit into the rift and a moment of calm is followed by a flash of red lightning, before the rift shoots out Blue Jeans!

Good idea, I'm curious to see how often it'll turn up in this thread. Good luck everyone!

You tossed your Lilac Visor into the rift and a moment of calm is followed by a flash of red lightning, before the rift shoots out Chocolate Bat Cookies!

You tossed your Item Hunters Monocle into the rift and a moment of calm is followed by a flash of red lightning, before the rift shoots out Lemon Cybill Footsicle!

[item2=Twilight Mortiking Slippers]

You tossed your Cherry Bubble Candy into the rift and a moment of calm is followed by a flash of red lightning, before the rift shoots out Twilight Mortiking Slippers!

not luck today either

You tossed your Microphone into the rift and a moment of calm is followed by a flash of red lightning, before the rift shoots out Yellow Leg Warmers!

You tossed your Box of Souls into the rift and a moment of calm is followed by a flash of red lightning, before the rift shoots out Pinkahhh!

You tossed your Which Stitch into the rift and a moment of calm is followed by a flash of red lightning, before the rift shoots out nothing at all. Guess you lost that one.

Atleast I got an achievement 🤷 Shifted by the Rift! Receive nothing from the rift. Multiple times.

You tossed your Sun Kanis Slippers into the rift and a moment of calm is followed by a flash of red lightning, before the rift shoots out Discarded Rift Tentacle!

You tossed your Bongo Drums into the rift and a moment of calm is followed by a flash of red lightning, before the rift shoots out Pedro!

You tossed your Arid Magnus Beanbag into the rift and a moment of calm is followed by a flash of red lightning, before the rift shoots out Red Tipped Carnation!

not that time

You tossed your 20th Anniversary Cream Kumos Cookie into the rift and a moment of calm is followed by a flash of red lightning, before the rift shoots out Old Wizard Hat!