Starfish Soup

Sake

[item2=Blueberry Jolly Roger]

Aww, how could Angrybeard hate something like this? You decide to pretend you didn't find anything and slip it into your pocket to give to one of your pets later as a minion.

Good job matey, ye've helped me get rid o' that stinkin' vermin! ...Avast ye, someone's been plunderin' me rum! It's that scallywag Dirty Matty!

Stargazey Pie

[item2=Cask of Rum]

Aye, thar be a particularly nasty one! Well done! Have some fresh grub on me fer all ye harrrd work.

Good job matey, ye've helped me get rid o' that stinkin' vermin! ...Avast ye, someone's been plunderin' me rum! It's that scallywag Dirty Matty!

Spicy Seaweed Salad

[item2=Octopus Rolls]

Good job matey, ye've helped me get rid o' that stinkin' vermin! ...Avast ye, someone's been plunderin' me rum! It's that scallywag Dirty Matty!

Codfish Fritters

Good job matey, ye've helped me get rid o' that stinkin' vermin! ...Avast ye, someone's been plunderin' me rum! It's that scallywag Dirty Matty!

Quick Rat

Aye, thar be a particularly nasty one! Well done! Have some fresh grub on me fer all ye harrrd work.

Purple Pirate Grapes

Good job matey, ye've helped me get rid o' that stinkin' vermin! ...Avast ye, someone's been plunderin' me rum! It's that scallywag Dirty Matty!

[ITEM2=Weevil Infested Ship Biscuit]

Probably Bread