[item2=stargazey pie]

Aye, thar be a particularly nasty one! Well done! Have some fresh grub on me fer all ye harrrd work. [item2=Pirate Spaghetti]

Treasure Map Pizza

Salt Cod

Good job matey, ye've helped me get rid o' that stinkin' vermin! ...Avast ye, someone's been plunderin' me rum! It's that scallywag Dirty Matty!

Pirate Treasure Pizza

[item2=Sole Meuniere]

Aye, thar be a particularly nasty one! Well done! Have some fresh grub on me fer all ye harrrd work.

(It doesn't actually show me that I got an item, but I got Stargazey Pie in my inventory after the event, so that must be it)

Roast Suckling Pig

That's exactly right - it doesn't show you the item on the galley page, but it does show up in your inventory!

[item2=Pirate Orange]

[item2=Tuna Steak]

Battened Down Melon

Lagan and Derelict

[item2=Rum Pancakes]

[item2=Salt Cod]

Curly Calamari

Good job matey, ye've helped me get rid o' that stinkin' vermin! ...Avast ye, someone's been plunderin' me rum! It's that scallywag Dirty Matty!

[item2=Green Pirate Apple]