It may be that the page refreshed and used it before. The rreign only accepts items with "red rreign" in the name so if you have other items with that in the item name it should work. The wreathed items do have a chance of making the rreign mad and THEN he can burn other items but it does not happen everytime. You can also get singed or burned items. Please let me know if I am not making sense xD

Has your issue been answered by the posts above?