You pop the balloon and out falls:

1 Carnival Ticket

and 10,972 sP

Surprise! You also get this old trick or treat item:

[item2=Licorice Grape Ghost]

Triple-Tailed Interdimensional Rift Monster Plushie

You pop the balloon, and nothing falls out! Aww, too bad!

You pop the balloon and out falls:

1 Carnival Ticket and 12,762 sP

Surprise! You also get this old trick or treat item: Minty Miscreant

You pop the balloon, and nothing falls out! Aww, too bad!

You pop the balloon and out falls:

1 Carnival Ticket

and 13,926 sP

Surprise! You also get this old trick or treat item:

[item2=Nuclear Candy Bracelet]

You pop the balloon, and nothing falls out! Aww, too bad!

You pop the balloon and out falls:

1 Carnival Ticket

and 14,130 sP

Surprise! You also get this old trick or treat item:

[item2=Cola Laces]

You pop the balloon and out falls:

1 Carnival Ticket

and 8,586 sP

Surprise! You also get this old trick or treat item:

[item2=Red Skull Votive Candle]

You pop the balloon, and nothing falls out! Aww, too bad!

You pop the balloon, and nothing falls out! Aww, too bad!

You pop the balloon, and nothing falls out! Aww, too bad!

You pop the balloon, and nothing falls out! Aww, too bad!

You pop the balloon, and nothing falls out! Aww, too bad!

You pop the balloon, and nothing falls out! Aww, too bad!

You pop the balloon, and nothing falls out! Aww, too bad!

You pop the balloon, and nothing falls out! Aww, too bad!

You pop the balloon and out falls:

1 Carnival Ticket

and 6,146 sP

Surprise! You also get this old trick or treat item:

Closed Fang Inserts

You pop the balloon and out falls:

1 Carnival Ticket

and 13,139 sP

Surprise! You also get this old trick or treat item: Purple Spider Ring

You pop the balloon, and nothing falls out! Aww, too bad!