Okay you make some good points. These are all usable now. The only thing I passed on are the meltybears as minions.

Books: SAI Morse Code Legend Unopened Letter from Jules

Food: Severed Goat Head Old Corn Husk Equinox Apple Warding Witch Cake Spiral Gourd Lantern (this feels like a stretch but since it is literally useless ENJOY PETS) Eddie Bell Kebab Pepper Heels Eddie Bell Kebab Onion Dress Eddie Bell Kebab Pepper Hat Eddie Bell Kebab Grilled Pants Eddie Bell Kebab Pepper Belts Eddie Bell Bravocado Body Paint Pie Mace Chaotic Goop Evil Goop Vesnali Picnic Basket Geldrop Lil Glider Jamba Elixir of Love

Minion: Jelly Bean Poopin Reindeer (also toy, why not) Goop Dark Dust Stinky Dust Preserved Eyeball in a Jar Preserved Snake in a Jar Preserved Spider in a Jar

Toy: Jelly Bean Poopin Reindeer

Sorry for not tagging the group! I was too ahead of myself earlier. It's on my notepad widget even! Also, see below:

Got it! Stars Gourd Lantern is now edible. Gross.

READABLE

• Calendarat

EDIBLE:

• Cozy Pumpkins
• Lovely Fruit Hat
• Baklaclava
• Delish Sharp Banana
• Delish Devoted Bag of Tasty Grains
• Delish Brave Feed
• Delish Loyal Wolf
• Delish Inclined Pouch of Acorns
• Frugala Blub
• Bubble Gum Blub
• Greedy Guts

MINION:

• Bottled Spirit

===

To think on / Potential No:

• Paper: I mean… it’s blank.
• Bamboo Tumblers: Do these fall in the “is there anything in there” category??
• Eddie Bell Sure Bet Cute Popsicle Prop: The desc leads to it not being edible!
• Why do you want to eat grass seeds

(Doing these between other projects, so I didn't get to everything in the first post. These are just my notes as of right now!)

Just an update, I've made all the blubs that weren't edible edible! Enjoy those delicious blobby minions. ;)

As far as old plot items becoming something else (the poster being readable), things like that I'm working on bringing back! Plot things that don't fit in the antique shop (battle, achievement prize, etc) are things we have to get a little creative with. 👀

Please ping me on things y'all have questions about or would like a bit more rationale behind the choices! I'm happy to discuss. :)

, , , , and are all edible now!

To do some small part in alleviating the candy cane shortage, and are also both edible now. :)

Sorry for all the pings! One more for the road:

can also now be fed to your pet!

The , , , and have been made into food!

The Empty [etc] Wrappers are not going to be made edible, under the same reasoning as empty cups or other containers not being made edible.

The has been made edible! I personally didn't realize that banana stems and banana flowers are also consumed, but with that information it makes perfect sense.

Ah, good point! We'll take another look at the rest of the set.

Amber may want to do the honors on that one, I'll ping it to her now. Thank you for the mention of it!

I did indeed run this by Amber; the Decorative Elephant Teapot now has an updated description with tea in it, and is edible! Er, drinkable. Please enjoy your Friday night libation!

SORRY I haven't looked at this in a (long) while!

CHANGES, EXPLANATIONS, ETC ETC

The other basters aren't edible. Are you working under the assumption since it looks like there is some liquid in the baster, it should be edible? Oh, that's such a good item. Maybe I can rename it to be figurine or something so it makes more sense that it isn't an actual minion. Why would paper lanterns be minions? I don't know why I thought some of those were already edible. Delish Material Treat Pouch, Delish Nimble Cheese Platter Gift, and Delish Operose Bag of Morsels are all edible now. The egg's description says it's moving so it has dragon ready to pop out, I don't think that makes it edible at that point. Happy to discuss this further, though. For the Herbal Medicinal Wood, is it edible in that form? Or is it edible after you use it in stuff? Live Fishing Bait has been made edible. :) I'm curious - why do you think a dragon egg should be edible? Is it the same principal of you can eat duck (insert other animals like that) eggs? Could it be this dragon egg already has dragon inside, so no good for cooking/etc? It's not edible because it's not meant to be. It smells great for your hair, but don't eat it!! I actually checked directly with on those petrified fruits to see if they could be edible and was told they were basically rocks, so a no go! is correct, it's not meant to be actual food but you do chew on it.