I killed off all my archans, it feels terrible.

A broken sword? I mean, he is a blacksmith, he works with broken weapons on daily basis I guess?

Edit: used nothing but and nothing happened

Yeah, his fear could be someone getting hurt because of a mistake he made? He tries to avoid mistakes because he is so dependable.

ahhh I see I see! That actually makes a lot of sense! I'm sad it wasn't that because its a nice story!

- Yeah is probably regretting it already ;)

I just can't see it having anything to do with a cat since we've already had a challenger with a cat.

I'm trying a weak pet, but maybe it needs to be a pet with basic stats? (no)

Lose with a Tigrean (no).

Make a sword, then lose with it. (no).

Make a sword, then have it break (no).

i regret nothing ever

The battle is only half the battle o-o; ba-dun-hiss

So we are expected to kill off one of our pets and than do something with it being ded, that is, not to heal it at the healer at least. Now when my Hipottu is dead I'm gonna roll it over shelves again.

Ok so wait..

Mathis doesn't like fighting since he usually is the one to step in and stop a fight....

So a battle ... and winding up pissing him off....

-thinks-

Using a Forj weapon in battle maybe? Just tossing out ideas. [edit] Nope... ok moving on.

lost to Prodigy using Nefertiti the Dark Matter Tigrean... AND THEN

EDIT: Actually a few of wesker's pets have lost to Prodigy... but only once (their only battle)

I was thinking about Dark Matter pets but they the potion is expensive for people to buy it just to "try out" a possibility imo

True....though, my battle pet is Dark Matter...

What about visiting him while in battle? Like going to his shop in a new window?

ive been in the wardrobe for 2.5 hours now trying to find items that go with these clues. Does it have anything to do with wardrobe?

Nope, from all the other Friendly Thursday challengers and unlocking them, it's a new way, which is not connected to the others. So basically no wearing items, deleting, etc. Something else entirely.

thanks now i can move on.

Like said, there was already a challenger that required wardrobe items. This one does not. There was also a challenger that required your pet to have 0 health so just battling to lose is not the answer. There is one other thing that you need when you lose and it has to deal with what would make Mathis mad. It's sort of the opposite of the things he likes. I was too morbid with my first guess xD

Yeah that was from the last challenger I had to unlock. Hence, the "hello darkness my old friend"

The opposite of what he likes? So...kinda like if he liked coffee and someone gave him tea?(bad example)

- Ohhh.... I'm looking way too far into this ahaha.

but like worse than that. Giving a coffee lover tea is no reason for them to want to fight you, but dumping hot coffee on them would be a reason.

Battling and losing... opposite of his likes.

Likes: Victoria, Cats, mountain retreats and building stuff/forging items....

Dislikes: Actual fighting, would rather avoid.

: hmm ok I know I am no help, I am just going over everything.

I dunno...I'm a coffee drinker and if someone offered me tea.... ;)

So....we kill one of our pets, and then...I dunno, scream Victoria sucks at our computer screen?