I don't do this often. I just stick them in storage and go do a bunch at once. I haven't done any for a while, guess its time :).

Dark Mage Amulet x 20 Earth Mage Amulet x10 Death Mage Amulet x 15

Results: Darkness Shard x17 Earth Shard x9 Death Shard x12

Tome of Darkness x3 Tome of Earth x1 Tome of Death x3

7 out of 45. No idea what's a typical amount to get.

In addition to the random mage amulet I received earlier, Quentin gave me 5 more!

Omg I preffer to sell them in my shop lol

Thank you for bringing me my amulet! You have been a great help! As promised, here is your gift:

[item2=Life Shard]

Fire Mage Amulet x15 Ice Mage Amulet x15 Life Mage Amulet x20

Fire Shard x12 Ice Shard x13 Life Shard x19

Tome of Fire x3 Tome of Ice x2 Tome of Life

6 out of 50, not as good as yesterday.

Light Mage Amulet x15 Magma Mage Amulet x15 Water Mage Amulet x15 Wind Mage Amulet x10

Light Shard x14 Magma Shard x15 Water Shard x12 Wind Shard x8

Tome of Light x1 Tome of Water x3 Tome of Wind x2

6 out of 55, hmmm, getting worse every day.

As promised, here is your gift:

[item2=Darkness Shard]

Death Mage Amulet x25 Earth Mage Amulet x10 Water Mage Amulet x10

Death Shard x19 Earth Shard x10 Water Shard x9

Tome of Death x6 Tome of Water x1

7 out of 45, hmmm, seems like turning in 45 amulets produces the best results. LOL but my sample size is tiny.

i tend to do mine in batches when i get sick of seeing them in my inventory XD today i turned in = and received Dark x1 = shard x1 Death x1 = tome x1 Fire x1 = shard x1 Magma x2 = shard x2 Light x1 = shard x1 Wind x1 = shard x1

i've been keeping track for aaaages trying to figure out which amulets are statistically better for me to turn in vs sell, and after finding Water amulets have a terrible ratio, i still end up turning them in :I

As promised, here is your gift:

Life Shard

Dark Mage Amulet x8 Earth Mage Amulet x8 Fire Mage Amulet x10 Life Mage Amulet x2 Magma Mage Amulet x11 Water Mage Amulet x5 Wind Mage Amulet

Darkness Shard x6 Earth Shard x8 Fire Shard x8 Life Shard x2 Magma Shard x10 Wind Shard

Tome of Darkness x2 Tome of Fire x2 Tome of Magma Tome of Water

6 out of 45, I'm liking turning in 45. Gonna have to do more quentin quests to rebuild my stash though.

interesting stats - I seem to get a lot death tomes too.

today Quentin gave me an Ice amulet. Mage turned it into a shard

Thank you for bringing me my amulet! You have been a great help! As promised, here is your gift:

Death Shard

Haven't had time to do quetin quests. Sigh.

As promised, here is your gift:

[item2=Tome of Water]

As promised, here is your gift:

Death Shard

another inventory clear-out Death Shard Life Shard Light Shard Wind Shard Ice Shard

I always sell my amulets - I can tell you if I got any from Quentin. (I did actually get a nice haul this time, four of them - ice, life, magma, and dark.)