ok so 10000000% carl like lets be honest, have you seen some of the stuff you can get from him? he's clearly great at gathering some swanky nice items we'd find all the best treasure due to him surely, my metal detector will prob pic up like 1 quarter?? if im lucky?

also carl bonus: he falls asleep?????!? um i can slowly take the better stuff he found? he never seemed to mind right? hes just a hoarder, we both benefit.

edit carl bonus bonus: he totally knows how to have a good time. so like, if we get lost and totally never make it to the island (dude its possible?) or those who said there was tREASURE ARE BIG FAT LIARS we can still have a rowdy time out at sea i am down to get down with my mans sleepy c'

i would definitely choose saggittarius, he may be pompous but he knows value when he sees it, and i totally would want someone as passionate about treasures as i am to come with as to not slow me down!

I would want angrybeard with me to cook all my food and keep me company plus he is big and strong for carrying the treasure. Also since he is a pirate bringing him along would keep away those pesky theft allegations.

I'd want to bring the Tempest to sail with me to the treasure island! She spends so much time showering us with gifts for hanging out with her, it's time she got some pretty trinkets. c; Plus bear hugs. Bear hugs are good.

I would take saggi he kinda looks like a pirate right? He is also really good at battle and traveling via the last plot when we went on a trip with him. He is a tough cookie and I would like him on my side.

I would want to sail away with SubetaTeam... think about it, if you are stuck on a boat with nothing to entertain yourselves with but each other, SubetaTeam has no big personality, so there would be no major personality clashes to drive you guys crazy in the confines of a boat, and he is always giving us cool updates so he is clearly well-informed. He will probably find the treasure first and inform the rest of us of its discovery ;) hahaha

Matlal because he is hilarious, and would be a lot of fun to hang around with! Plus, he'd be an immense help finding food to eat, building a fire, etc

That's easy, Allard- he is a wizard- we can get out of trouble and wouldn't steal my part like Sagi would. XD

I would want to bring Sarah with me because she's just so sweet and I feel like she could really use some adventure! ^_^

Blake Steele of course. I mean, who else would be as useful at finding treasure?

My first instinct is to pick Sag for obvious reasons but I'm slightly afraid that his passion for treasure might be too passionate...so I'm going to take Pete so he can make me roasted fingers and other mammal bits. No I'm joking, he'll make me ice cream and desserts from (hopefully) the fruits we find on the island.

YOU CAN'T JOURNEY OR ADVENTURE ON AN EMPTY STOMACH

i would want to bring rita because she knows how to handle being on ship so i know i would feel safe and she was the one to suggest that cats be let on board the freyalise so she is extra cool in my book and we would probably bring as many cats as we can for the journey to find the treasure!

I think I might go with Bubbles, the shop keeper at the Lost Skeleton. In the Subetapedia it says he loves puns and is friends with rats, and honestly? Rats are everywhere, including islands, maybe we could get some help with them? Rats know things And also.. Puns. Puns are good. Puns are great and I need them. I mean if we're talking pirates,we already know their favorite letter. Do you?

And I mean, he only has one arm so he has full rights to jokes like these:

Like honestly the real treasure was the friend I made along the way and his god dang puns. Bless this man. tho the real treasure would be bomb too let's be real

If I were setting sail for a deserted island rumored to be full of pirate treasure, the subeta NPC I would want to go with me is Blake Steele because his passion is archaeology and treasure hunting and if I'm going to be looking for lost pirate treasure I can't think of anyone better to help me find it. I'm sure if I run out of idea of where to look, he'll have plenty of experience to guide our way. And if we run across any 'mysterious' items in the treasure he'll have a better idea of whether it's dangerous or not. Plus he could probably strum up some helping hands if we find something really big and need help digging it all out ;)

Carl, he a is a great thief. Have you seen the stuff he's gotten off the Freyalise? On our journey back I could just get him drunk until he's Ko'd, go through his pockets because he's definitely hiding stuff and then ditch him.

Oh my gosh, I love this challenge! lol If I were on a deserted island with tons of treasure I would want to be stuck on it with Luna (does she count???) Because dogs are the best friend and companion and they can help protect you from bad animals/pirates. If she does not count then I would choose Mathis (hotness right there!!!) because he is very outdoorsy and can probably build us a tree house to live in. :D

Hmmm... I guess I'll say Saggi. Because I'm sure he has a nose for anything valuable.

Um...we're talking about treasure, right? Who else to bring but Blake Steele? He's a treasure hunter galore, right? Plus, he'd probably keep interesting company (with stories and enthusiasm and all that!)!

It'd be Blake for me. He's cute, and funny, plus he's adventurous so there'd be a lot of things we could do. I have a feeling it would not be boring.

I talked to PaisleyAnn over text and she is going to try to be on as soon as possible. There's a pretty serious storm in her area that isn't letting her get online at the moment.