There are so many.

SPOILER (click to toggle)

I think these two are the only ones that emit a knee-jerk reaction of disgust from me, it's got something to do with the clutter / trypo hole texture that's making me really uneasy. I still want that Mahar though, the design is one of my favorites on the entire site. The art is superb, but horrifying.

SPOILER (click to toggle)

I don't really even have any particular snake phobia, but there's something about the BR serpenth's body that's absolutely terrifying.

demon possession. That's all I'm going to say. It's the empty eyes that are really, really sinister.

I'm loving that the thread has various Nostalgic pets too. Living toys, huh... Chucky, anyone?

Omg. I'll never be able to see the angelic manchu the same way again lmao I don't think theres a graveyard pet I actually like, but there's a few that bother me more than others.

SPOILER (click to toggle)

This experiment has always bothered me, idk I think its the fact the eyes wrap around the bowl....thing.

This one just makes me sad.

EXPOSTED SPINES MORE LIKE NO THANKS.

nope.

I dislike the Sweetheart Dillema for the same reason... no bodysuit, but it has that same expression. shudder

And re: lots of replies about eyeballs... I actually love eyeballs (and have a collection of eyeball knick knacks), so I love the GY Mahar, peacock experiment, etc ^X^; Yes, the fluffy cutesy balloon overlord also has a dark side :P

I actually like the GY Ghostly, but then Ghostlies are my fav pet... and I have a BR Serpenth and love the design because it has great hair >X>

The bloodred hippotu is pretty scary in my opinion. Check out those teeth, not friendly at all.

Also shout out for the Nostalgic Warador, which is a creepy jack-in-the-box. I find most Waradors to be quite scary.