Okay, I wasn't sure if they could check into it or not. I'll file a report to the programmers. Sorry! :(

I am SO sorry that I never tested this before now x.x I was really absent minded and forgot! But I did finally test it and...

The Gift Exchange sends a notice that the Dawn Velosotor Elixir you put up for exchange did not find a match within the 2 and a half day time limit. The item has been returned to you. Please feel free to try again.

[edit]Wait a minute....I DID remember and I think all of them were just returned xD

The Gift Exchange sends a notice that the Smoothing Hair Tonic you put up for exchange did not find a match within the 2 and a half day time limit. The item has been returned to you. Please feel free to try again.

I'M SORRY I DON'T THINK IT GOT YOUR PING, THAT OR IT GOT LOST IN THE SEA OF PINGS....[S]REALLY, I WAS IGNORING YOU[/S]

That's weird that it took so long I'm going to try and find out if that's intentional or not. :o

EDIT Do you remember if you EVER got the item back? Undoubtedly finally got it back after about a week.

I did get them back but it was a longer wait than the 2 1/2 days.