Ok I'm sure there are a few topics on this wishing shrub now but I get to complain too ok.

I'm all for trying your luck with expensive things. Heck! First day, I asked for a Gift of Fashions Past, and got mad lucky that someone was so generous! But you can't always bet on that And pretty much every wish in there right now is 10+ mil and up, or not even being sold (at least have the decency to check if a granter can even GET the item for you for goodness sake.) After a few hours.....I think it's not a stretch to think to yourself "this isn't happening, maybe I should lower my expectations a bit. It was a nice try, but..." Cus otherwise, you won't get an item at ALL, won't get the achievement if you keep pullin that junk, AND you're not letting any other users try. So it's kind of...not only a jerk move but kind of stupid? Like, fine, try, good luck! But realize that if it's not happening, it's not happening, and try to get another item that you want that might actually HAPPEN. Bah. Excuse me I'm in a foul mood, so. But. BAH.

Im actually grateful for all the people who ask for stupid stuff, while they are in la la land, I'm getting my wishes filled with no problem c:

Not anymore you're not. You have to grant a wish before you make one now

i haven't even granted a single wish or made any of my own yet, because it just seems like too much of a gamble. i can understand why people are asking for expensive items, since most of them are fairly expensive, but i don't understand why people are asking for items that cost way more than average. i agree that it doesn't make sense that people are asking for items that aren't even available in shops.

i haven't even granted a single wish or made any of my own yet, because it just seems like too much of a gamble. i can understand why people are asking for expensive items, since most of them are fairly expensive, but i don't understand why people are asking for items that cost way more than average. i agree that it doesn't make sense that people are asking for items that aren't even available in shops.

I haven't had much issue in that regard. I see something in my vault that is rotting away anyway, so I use it. No big loss.

there's a few things that i see only one of each day and i wonder if its the same person really hoping someone will gift them that mega expensive thing they want by the end of the event.

It really is annoying. I still have yet to find a wish I can fulfill. I myself ask for items that are less than 10 mil.

Not true. I have been able to make wishes without needing to grant one the past 4 days including today

Yesterday I saw the same 28 500csc cards sitting the shrub all day long. I don't think they were ever granted.

((Btw...that's my name, so in a way I am pinging myself))

Well then, i must be unlucky or have bad timing because when I tried to make a wish, I got to error monster telling me "Oh no! You have to grant a wish before making a wish"

I know right at midnight if you're really quick you can make a wish without granting one first.

Nope! Not a bug c: I asked earlier today here for confirmation,

So you can either get lucky at random points during the day, or try to be really quick at midnight when the pool resets c:

You'd think after 4-5 days they understand that such expensive wishes aren't getting fulfilled, no matter how long you keep them up. And how the Wishing Shrub works right now they could have use these days to wish for expensive things under 10 millions, which is still way more than enough. Right now they're just going to end up with nothing. Maybe they just don't understand that other users have to fulfill these wishes, and the Wishing Shrub is not randomly giving out things. But again, they should know by now.

Word! I've gotten some neato stuff, keeping it cheaper means my wishes get granted almost immediately!

I just don't get why people keep wishing for crazy stuff though, maybe they would rather hope they'll get that one huge thing than ask for reasonable things every day. I dunno :/

- Hard to get people to do the smart thing when they read other bragging threads regarding high priced stuff that's been gifted. So it's just natural for them to sit there hoping someone will gift them what they want

I guess. =.=

Guess I won't be granting any wishes. Would be nice. :(

Thank you for confirming that it's not a bug!

Not a problem! I was happy to hear an official word on it as well ^^