You Win:

Anglerfish
How did you manage to get that far away from the treasure?
You Win:
Gulper Eel
You were so close!
You Win: [item2=Nuclear Rave Fish] If you had just gotten a little closer!
You Win:
Merdra
If you had just gotten a little closer!
You Win:
Subetian Fish Hook
How did you manage to get that far away from the treasure?
You Win:
Tadpole with Legs
You were nowhere near it!
You Win:
Bagged Swordtail Fish
You were so close!